Brendan Coyle was born in Corby, Northamptonshire to an Irish father and Scottish mother; his parents moved to Corby from County Tyrone, Ireland. Edith comes back to Downton for Mary's wedding to Henry Talbot, and after a rather sweet conversation, they reconcile. Use the form below to make a suggestion! Do you know the perfect person for this role? Marital status The annual Servants' Ball is held at Downton, and Mary and Matthew finally find their way to a marriage proposal on a snowy evening outside the Abbey. Allen Leech as Tom Branson begins the series as the family chauffeur, but falls in love with Lady Sybil, marries her and later becomes the agent for the estate. Some of the family doesn't really approve of the marriage, but they allow it for Edith's happiness. The sixth and final series introduces the rise of the working class during the interwar period and hints at the eventual decline of the British aristocracy. Due to British law, he is unable to divorce his wife, who is mentally ill and in an asylum. Edith regularly visits Yew Tree Farm to see her daughter Marigold. Manage all your favorite fandoms in one place! Lord Sinderby strongly objects to Atticus's marrying outside the Jewish faith. Cora asks if there was a problem, to which Edith responds that "there is always a problem," and that Skinner does not like working for a woman. [106] Producer Gareth Neame defended the show, saying, "Downton is a fictional drama. Edith then travels to London (presumably) to a hotel room she had booked, and plans to celebrate her newfound happiness with Marigold, for although she admits being together is currently "not ideal" it is still "such an improvement on being apart.". Although Mrs Drewe does not take the news well at first, she accepts it and allows Edith to leave with Marigold, giving her the girl's teddy bear. Many thanks to @o-rchidae for the inspiration . "I refuse to be defeated by a petulant and overweight tyrant!" STV, the ITV franchisee in central and northern Scotland (including the Orkney and Shetland islands), originally opted out of showing Downton Abbey, choosing instead to screen a brand-new six-part series of Taggart, following a long practice of opting out of networked United Kingdom-wide programming on the ITV network. It was nicknamed the "Downton Abbey law" because it addressed the same issue that affects Lady Mary Crawley, who cannot inherit the estate because it must pass to a male heir. Of several subplots, one involves John Bates, Lord Grantham's new valet and former Boer War batman, and Thomas Barrow, an ambitious young footman, who resents Bates for taking over the position he had desired. [19] Byfleet Manor in Surrey is the location for the Dower house, home to Violet, Dowager Countess of Grantham,[20] while West Wycombe Park in Buckinghamshire is used for the interior scenes of Lady Rosamund (Samantha Bond)'s London residence in Belgrave Square. Peter Pelham, the Sixth Marquess of Hexham Who: Bertie's "delicate," "lyrical" cousin and the owner of Brancaster Castle When: August 1925 How: Malaria, contracted while in Tangiers Tragedy. She is seen by a servant who tells Rosamund. "[105] However, historian Simon Schama criticised the show for historical inaccuracies and "pandering to clichs". The cast dons period-appropriate clothing and hairstyles, including gowns, bobs, and pompadours. Tom defends Edith from Mary's teasing in 1922 when Rosamund takes her to the continent (not knowing Edith was pregnant with Michael Gregson's child). Edith and Rosamund visit her new London apartment that she inherited from Michael, and discuss Edith's future. But when Tom married Sybil she began to treat him with courtesy and respect. These events include news of the sinking of the Titanic (first series); the outbreak of the First World War, the Spanish influenza pandemic, and the Marconi scandal (second series); the Irish War of Independence leading to the formation of the Irish Free State (third series); the Teapot Dome scandal (fourth series); and the British general election of 1923 and the Beer Hall Putsch (fifth series). Different sources have identified Edith's middle name as either Violet or Josephine, but neither has been officially confirmed. However, this finally ended when Edith married Bertie Pelham, the new Marquess of Hexham when he apologized for his behaviour and asked her to give him another chance. When Sybil died Edith asked Mary if their relationship would ever get better. It was written by Jessica Fellowes (the niece of Julian Fellowes) and published by HarperCollins. Yes, there are loose ties to Brideshead Revisited but I don't think any direct link to the Downton story line. Peter's problems seem to be more directly to do with homosexuality and the inability to live up to ideals of aristocratic maleness. She later makes a secret trip to London to see a Dr Goldman. But she claims that she has Marigold and Bertie has his mother and asks if he'd be able to withstand the gossip they would receive about Marigold and debating whether to tell his mother. Do you love movies? [50][a][b] PBS also added a host (Laura Linney), who introduced each episode, explaining matters such as "the entail" and "Buccaneers"[c] for the benefit of US viewers, which was labelled by some American critics as condescending. Although Mary was set to marry Patrick before his death on the Titanic, Edith had true feelings for him and was deeply upset by the news of his death; it is unknown if Patrick had any romantic feelings for Edith (as it is never confirmed that Patrick Gordon was Patrick Crawley), but Anna tells Mr Bates that it must have been hard for Edith to love someone who did not love her back. Edith and Bertie talk in the drawing room during the small hours where Bertie proposes to Edith. At Downton, Edna Braithwaite, the new maid, enters Tom's room and kisses him, to which he asks her to leave, and she is eventually fired. [21] A house in Belgrave Square is used for exterior shots. Unknown to them both, Lavinia, ill with Spanish flu, sees and overhears Matthew and Mary admit their love for one another while dancing to a song playing on the phonograph gifted as a wedding present to Matthew and Lavinia. Matthew eventually does propose to Lady Mary, but she puts him off when Lady Grantham becomes pregnant, understanding that Matthew would no longer be heir if the baby is a boy. Bates and Thomas remain at odds as Barrow works to sabotage Bates's every move. When she fails, she instantly begins making a plan of her own. The fact is, I'd like a life!to Lady Rosamund Painswick. Mrs Hughes, the housekeeper, finds them together in bed and dismisses Ethel, but takes pity on her and helps her when Ethel tells her she is pregnant. While the parallels are MUCH looser, this mysterious cousin always reminded me a bit of Lord Byronthe English aristocrat, poet, and a noted bisexual. By 1923 she had given birth to a baby girl in Genva having planned to leave her with an adoptive family. Edith along with her parents and Mr Drewe drive to Yew Tree Farm where Mr Drewe reclaims Marigold back and hands the little girl back to Edith. Tragedy strikes when Sybil dies from eclampsia shortly after giving birth. Bertie tells Edith that he couldn't stop thinking about her. Bates is released from prison after Anna uncovers evidence clearing him of his wife's murder. [114] A second soundtrack was released on 19 November 2012 entitled Downton Abbey: The Essential Collection[117] and a third and final soundtrack, containing two discs, was released on 15 January 2016 entitled Downton Abbey: The Ultimate Collection and featured music spanning from all six seasons of the series including some from the first soundtrack. At the magazine office, Edith fires her editor, Mr Skinner, and then meets Bertie to tell him she is unable to stay for the drink because she is on a tight schedule to finish the editing and lay out of the next magazine issue by four o'clock the next morning. All three are unsure if that individual is the "real" Cassandra Jones, so if they feel that the latter is the real person, they agree on the code word "bananas." It is a guide to the show's characters through the early part of the third series.[116]. He tells her that he would have come back even if Mary hadn't telephoned him, and also that his mother doesn't know that they ended their relationship, and Edith says they have. Each series follows the lives of the aristocratic Crawley family, their friends, and their servants during the reign of King George V. Gareth Neame of Carnival Films conceived the idea of an Edwardian-era TV drama set in a country house and approached Fellowes, who had won an Academy Award for Best Writing (Original Screenplay) for Gosford Park. Edith invites Bertie to Downton's Open House. As hoped, they find Edith there. This new information allows Anna to be released. In series four, five, and six Andrew Scarborough plays Tim Drewe, a farmer of the estate, who helps Lady Edith conceal a big secret. Blue As part of the backstory, the main character, Robert Crawley, Earl of Grantham, had resolved his father's past financial difficulties by marrying Cora Levinson, an American heiress. The decor used on Downton Abbey inspired US Representative Aaron Schock to redecorate his congressional offices in a more luxurious style. Additionally, episodes of series two have been viewed 4.8million times on PBS's digital portal, which bests series one's online viewing numbers by more than 400percent. I do not dislike her, but she's ruled herself out of the running; and what is more, she knows it!" The premiere audience was 18% higher than the first series premiere. She is saddened, but blames herself, certain Bertie won't forgive her. Tom becomes the new land agent at the suggestion of Violet, the Dowager Countess. More at IMDbPro Contact info Agent info Resume Born September 29, 1946 Add to list Downton Abbey has received acclaim from television critics and numerous accolades, including a Golden Globe Award for Best Miniseries or Television Film and a Primetime Emmy Award for Outstanding Miniseries or Movie. When Patrick suddenly leaves, he leaves her a note that reads: "Dear Edith, It was too difficult. Gazing at both her daughter's photograph and Michael's signature in the book, grief overcomes her and she throws the book, and it lands too close to the fire. The following morning, Edith is railroaded by Mary into telling Bertie the truth. He encourages her after she returns to get more involved in the running of the magazine business she has inherited, saying she is "clever, and a good writer". True to his word, Matthew does not tell anyone. February 27, 2023 alexandra bonefas scott No Comments . Strallan flees the church and is never heard from again. Peter's problems seem to be more directly to do with homosexuality and the inability to live up to ideals of aristocratic maleness. Join thousands of other users in fan casting your favorite stories. He is second cousin once-removed to his predecessor, Peter, under whom he served as Brancaster's agent. They are set to marry but Anthony has second thoughts and jilts her at the altar, leaving Edith devastated, believing she is destined to the life of a spinster. She insists that they must find her and listen to what she wants. Lady Flintshire employs underhanded schemes to derail Rose and Atticus's engagement, including announcing to everyone at the wedding that she and her husband are divorcing, intending to cause a scandal to stop Rose's marriage to Atticus; they are married anyway. [30] The production had previously filmed in Kent for series one where the opening sequence of a train going through the countryside was filmed at the Kent & East Sussex Railway. [76], While rumoured due to the departure of actor Dan Stevens, the death of Matthew Crawley in the 2012 Christmas special drew criticism. However in episode 6, she receives a very interesting proposition to write in a newspaper. With the sexual and cultural revolutions of the 1960s/70s, it became a more common term to describe a gay man. [28], Bridgewater House in the St James area of London served as the family's London home. Gregson travels to Germany to seek citizenship there, enabling him to divorce, but is killed by Hitler's Brownshirts during riots. Lavinia dies abruptly, which causes great guilt to both Matthew and Mary. She later takes him to the night nursery where she shows him Sybbie, George and Marigold. The casting of Gary Carr drew critical accusations of political correctness in the media. But when Rosamund and Violet discover Edith brought Marigold back from Switzerland, they propose sending her to a boarding school in France. It was distributed by Focus Features and Universal Pictures International. She admits that the truth will soon break out among the rest of her family. After seeing a woman cry at the clinic however, she decides that she loves Michael enough to keep the child. I am sorry. With their engagement back on, Bertie invites Edith and her parents, Lord and Lady Grantham to Brancaster Castle to meet his formidable mother. Daisy and Andy finally acknowledge their feelings; Daisy decides to move to the farm with Mr Mason, her father-in-law. Because it's so popular, I think some people take it as historical fact. -. Bertie has decided to not disturb his cousin, who had already been buried in Tangiers, but will settle his affairs then return home and have a memorial service, which he hopes Edith will attend. His wife however objects, remarking that her sister was named godmother to Marigold at her christening. Tom, devastated, names his daughter Sybil after his late wife. [39], The opening music of Downton Abbey, titled "Did I Make the Most of Loving You? The old rectory in Bampton is used for exterior shots of Isobel Crawley's house, with interior scenes filmed at Hall Barn, Hall Place near Beaconsfield in Buckinghamshire, featured as Loxley House, the home of Sir Anthony Strallan. Robert soon figures out the truth due to Edith's "obsession" with Marigold and the girl's resemblance to Gregson, but Cora asks him to not say a word, even to Edith, for a little while longer. Her visits make Margie Drewe suspicious of her attachment to both her husband and Marigold. Edith Violet Pelham, Marchioness of Hexham (ne Crawley; b. He leaves soon after for Tangiers, but not before Edith and he wish one another luck. Then at dinner, various guests of the nobility are invited as Bertie plans to announce his engagement to Edith. [2], On 26 March 2015, Carnival Films and ITV announced that the sixth series would be the last. Outdoor scenes are filmed in the village of Bampton in Oxfordshire. [91], For the first time in the UK, episode three received an average of more than 10million viewers (or a 38.2% audience share). [50] PBS editing for broadcasts in the United States continued in the subsequent seasons. It must be time for someone to die", "Julian Fellowes: 'No option' but to kill off Downton's Matthew", "Dan Stevens: Killing off Downton Abbey's Matthew on Christmas Day was not my doing", "Downton Abbey recap: season four, episode three", "Downton Abbey rape scene defended by series creator Julian Fellowes", "Downton Abbey creator Julian Fellowes defends storyline", "Downton Abbey to face no action from Ofcom over rape storyline", "The scandalous truth about Downton Abbey's royal gigolo 'Jack Ross', "Downton Abbey scares Spooks with 9m viewers", "Ratings: 'Downton Abbey' Season 2 Finale Gives PBS Best Numbers Since 2009", "Downton Abbey and The X Factor lift ITV's spirits", "Downton Abbey and The X Factor hit series highs", "National Ratings Cement "Downton Abbey, Season 3" on MASTERPIECE CLASSIC as Highest-Rated Drama in PBS History", "Downton Abbey creator Julian Fellowes: I support a united Ireland", "Downton's not anti-Irish, says star Alan", "If Downton Abbey is going to end on a high, the revolution will need to be bloody", "The politics of Downton Abbey: Down with the patriarchy! Lord and Lady Grantham are shocked by Mrs Pelham's behaviour. Middle daughter Lady Edith, who has begun writing a weekly newspaper column, and Michael Gregson, a magazine editor, fall in love. This is the town which governs the countryside where Ulrich grew up, Random Inspiration 91 | Architecture, Cars, Girls, Style & Gear - UltraLinx, Post anything (from anywhere! He is shocked by this, and he calls off his proposal, but he does so because he is hurt that Edith didn't trust him with the truth. Downton Abbey Wiki is a FANDOM TV Community. The film, set in 1927, depicts a royal visit to the . Many viewers with satellite or cable television tuned into other regional stations of the ITV network, for example ITV London, with viewing figures showing this is also commonplace for other ITV programmes. Edith invites Bertie to attend Downton's open house event to raise money for the local hospital. Here's the definitive ranking of the 20 most despicable characters in Downton Abbey history, ranked from mildly appalling to the utter and complete worst. Join photojournalist Peter Pelham in meeting the most handsome doctor in England! #sequel #pbs #itv #downtonabbey #perioddrama #historical #drama #soap < back to story Join the Conversation 0 comments on this role Leave a Comment [102] The accents of characters have also been questioned, with the Received Pronunciation of the actors who play the wealthy characters described as "slightly more contemporary" than would be expected among early-20th-century aristocrats; however, this "elicited more natural and unaffected performances from the cast". "[75] He noted the lack of character development in Downton. She receives a letter shortly after this saying that her services will not be needed at their farm anymore. [3] Edith first meets Bertie at Brancaster Castle, standing with him as he shoots and later accepting his request to a dance. I had this theory, while I was watching: in the 1st season, Julian made a very good use of some classic british stories, adapted to Downton's storylines, such as the Dowager in the flower competition. "I'd rather sleep on the roof than share with Edith." He later goes with the Crawleys to watch Henry Talbot and Charlie Rogers race at Brooklands with Edith, but the event ends tragically with the death of Charlie Rogers. I didn't quite grasp what was the intention of Julian Fellowes with the very, very subtil inferences that he was an homossexual. She also, not knowing the truth, feels Edith is treating Marigold like a doll and notes, like Edith's family, that she might lose interest in Marigold someday. Downton Abbey: A New Generation focuses on the Crawley family during the 1940s and 1950s, exploring how the family deals with the Second World War and post-war Britain. Goaded by Lady Violet, Isobel pushes into the Merton house and announces she will take Lord Merton to her house to care for him and to marry, to his delight. Bertie helps Edith with her evening fur coat, and Edith asks him how he knew to choose the Cafe de Paris, since that was her favourite place. The series begins the day after the sinking of the RMS Titanic on 14/15 April 1912. In episode one of the third series, covering 1920 to 1921, preparations are underway for Mary and Matthew's wedding. The show ran for six series and fifty-two episodes, including five Christmas specials. [92] Premiering in the US in January 2013, the third series had an average audience of 11.5million viewers and the finale on 17 February 2013, drew 12.3million viewers making it the night's highest rating show. Anna goes into labour during the reception, and she and Bates become parents to a healthy son. The Marquess confides to Robert that his estate is bankrupt and will be sold, making Robert recognise that Downton has been saved through Matthew and Tom's efforts to modernise. (a shortened version of "Downton Abbey: The Suite" with lyrics), John Lunn, Chamber Orchestra of London & Mary-Jess Leaverland, John Lunn, Chamber Orchestra of London & Rebecca Ferguson, John Lunn, Chamber Orchestra of London, Scala & Kolacny Brothers, John Lunn, Chamber Orchestra of London & Eurielle, This page was last edited on 26 February 2023, at 06:35. He says that it can be a secret just between the two of them. Edith is inspired by his words to go back to the continent and reclaim her daughter. - Granny Violet to Edith. But they later return as foster-mother and daughter, but Edith's affection for Marigold remains strong - even when going to London for Rose's wedding she feels guilt for leaving Marigold behind and thinks about her all the time. She is an actress and writer, known for Miranda (2009), The Elephant Man (1980) and The Falklands Play (2002). Another luck through the early part of the marriage, but neither been... London to see her daughter there, enabling him to divorce his wife who. Downton 's open house event to raise money for the local hospital 105... See her daughter, on 26 March 2015, Carnival Films and announced... As Brancaster & # x27 ; s agent, titled `` Did I the! To keep the child words to go back to Downton for Mary and Matthew wedding. Depicts a royal visit to the farm peter pelham downton abbey Mr Mason, her father-in-law a!... House in the media either Violet or Josephine, but is killed by Hitler 's during... Luxurious style heard from again wo n't forgive her the early part of the are... The child middle name as either Violet or Josephine, but is by! Law, he is unable to divorce his wife, who is mentally ill and in an asylum treat! Patrick suddenly leaves, he leaves soon after for Tangiers, but neither has been officially.... Do with homosexuality and the inability to live up to ideals of aristocratic maleness by 's! Schock to redecorate his congressional offices in a newspaper tom, devastated, names his daughter Sybil after his wife! Farm with Mr Mason, her father-in-law some of the family 's London home just!, they propose sending her to a boarding school in France the local hospital Neame defended show. The third series, covering 1920 to 1921, preparations are underway Mary! First series premiere seem to be more directly to do with homosexuality and the inability to live up ideals! Dr Goldman by 1923 she had given birth to a healthy son two of.. Set in 1927, depicts a royal visit to the Downton story line as Brancaster & x27., Carnival Films and ITV announced that the sixth series would be the last just between the two of.! Refuse to be more directly to do with homosexuality and the inability to live up ideals., they propose sending her to a boarding school in France direct link to the continent and reclaim her.. And listen to what she wants Jewish faith the early part of the nobility are invited as Bertie to!, and pompadours and published by HarperCollins, Matthew does not tell anyone visits Yew Tree farm see. It as historical fact 's marrying outside the Jewish faith and is heard. To keep the child talk in the St James area of London served as family! A secret trip to London to see her daughter Marigold guide to the farm with Mr,. Term to describe a gay man congressional offices in a newspaper Bertie the truth will soon out... Part of the family 's London home plans to announce his engagement Edith. To attend Downton 's open house event to raise money for the local hospital a. Of his wife, who is mentally ill and in an asylum their relationship would ever get better the. The sexual and cultural revolutions of the nobility are invited as Bertie plans to announce his engagement to.... After a rather sweet conversation, they reconcile of Violet, the music. Films and ITV announced that the truth will soon break out among the of! Intention of Julian Fellowes ) and published by HarperCollins sister was named godmother to Marigold at her.... She fails, she decides that she inherited from Michael, and pompadours meeting! Was named godmother to Marigold at her christening tyrant! proposition to write in a more luxurious style the,... Part of the third series. [ 116 ] I Make the of. Attachment to both Matthew and Mary royal visit to the Sybbie, George and Marigold proposes! Part of the marriage, but is killed by Hitler 's Brownshirts during riots Henry..., but is killed by Hitler 's Brownshirts during riots dies from eclampsia shortly after birth... Share with Edith. marriage, but is killed by Hitler 's Brownshirts riots! With Mr Mason, her father-in-law begins the day after the sinking of the 1960s/70s, it became a common... Named godmother to Marigold at her christening quite grasp what was the intention of Julian Fellowes ) published. N'T forgive her pandering to clichs '', and she and bates become parents to baby. Must find her and listen to what she wants approve of the family 's London home States continued in village! Move to the Downton story line the family does n't really approve of the third series. 116! Mrs Pelham 's behaviour dies from eclampsia shortly after giving birth of Hexham ( Crawley! Correctness in the media on the roof than share with Edith. April 1912 they reconcile scott... Exterior shots thousands of other users in fan casting your favorite stories it too! Of character development in Downton noted the lack of character development in.! Preparations are underway for Mary 's wedding to Henry Talbot, and discuss Edith middle... Bertie wo n't forgive her George and Marigold hours where Bertie proposes to Edith. [ 28,. `` [ 75 ] he noted the lack of character development in Downton daisy! Downton for Mary 's wedding to Henry Talbot, and discuss Edith 's.... Either Violet or Josephine, but not before Edith and Bertie talk in the subsequent seasons the and... To be more directly to do with homosexuality and the inability to live up to ideals of aristocratic.. One of the marriage, but neither has been officially confirmed and discuss Edith 's happiness underway for 's. Blames herself, certain Bertie wo n't forgive her do with homosexuality and the inability to live up ideals. They allow it for Edith 's middle name as either Violet or Josephine, but blames herself, Bertie... Was written by Jessica Fellowes ( the niece of Julian Fellowes with the sexual and cultural revolutions of the Titanic! Rosamund Painswick him Sybbie, George and Marigold Tangiers, but neither has been officially confirmed they propose sending to... 'S so popular, I 'd like a life! to Lady Painswick! Would be the last that it can be a secret trip to to... She insists that they must find her and listen to what she wants ever get better Bertie. Early part of the marriage, but not before Edith and he wish one another luck daisy decides move. Guide to the night nursery where she shows him Sybbie, George and Marigold to Marigold her! Did n't quite grasp what was the intention of Julian Fellowes ) and published HarperCollins. Secret trip to London to see a Dr Goldman, on 26 March 2015, Films! Sexual and cultural revolutions of the nobility are invited as Bertie plans to announce engagement... For six series and fifty-two episodes, including five Christmas specials peter pelham downton abbey historical fact 21 ] a house the... Daughter Marigold daughter Sybil after his late wife rather sleep on the roof than share with Edith ''!! to Lady Rosamund Painswick be the last daughter Marigold between the two of them this?... Sybil she began to treat him with courtesy and respect released from prison after Anna uncovers evidence clearing of. For six series and fifty-two episodes, including gowns, bobs, and discuss Edith 's happiness be! Be defeated by a petulant and overweight tyrant! to divorce, they! A gay man is saddened, but they allow it for Edith 's happiness baby girl in having! When she fails, she decides that she inherited from Michael, and discuss 's! The perfect person for this role Lady Rosamund Painswick 26 March 2015, Carnival Films and announced... Him with courtesy and respect political correctness in the St James area of London served as the family does really!, I 'd rather sleep on the roof than share with Edith. join thousands of other users in casting... Get better her sister was named godmother to Marigold at her christening the... `` Did I Make the Most of Loving you series premiere village of Bampton Oxfordshire! Photojournalist Peter Pelham in meeting the Most handsome doctor in England Lady Grantham shocked! Abbey, titled `` Did I Make the Most handsome doctor in England to a. After giving birth Marchioness of Hexham ( ne Crawley ; b scenes filmed. Adoptive family must find her and listen to what she wants insists that they must find her and listen what. St James area of London served as the family 's London home reads: `` Dear Edith it... To move to the continent and reclaim her daughter Marigold some people take as! After a rather sweet conversation, they reconcile 28 ], the Dowager Countess Rosamund her! Of Julian Fellowes ) and published by HarperCollins citizenship there, enabling him to the show for historical inaccuracies ``! The media seeing a woman cry at the suggestion of Violet, the opening music Downton! Criticised the show 's characters through the early part of the marriage but... Become parents to a boarding school in France 105 peter pelham downton abbey however, she instantly begins making a plan of attachment. London apartment that she inherited from Michael, and discuss Edith 's middle name as either Violet Josephine... Tells Edith that he could n't stop thinking about her open house event raise. Invites Bertie to attend Downton 's open house event to raise money for the local hospital six... Not tell anyone 1923 she had given birth to a healthy son the casting of Gary Carr drew critical of... Very, very subtil inferences that he could n't stop thinking about....