So call it not only the end of hope for 10s of millions of Afghans, but the end of American credibility, the end of America as a force for righteousness in the world. Lions for Lambs is a 2007 American war drama film directed by Robert Redford about the connection between a platoon of United States soldiers in Afghanistan, a U.S. senator, a reporter, and a California college professor. Watching the slaughter of his heroic enemies, a German general remarked sadly, "Nowhere have I seen such lions led by such lambs." We Won't Be Fooled Again, by Steven Deace and Gregg Jackson, tells the story of lions led by lambs in another protracted conflict. distinguished service against Russian forces in Galicia. On this Wikipedia the language links are at the top of the page across from the article title. [12][13], Evelyn, Princess Blcher, an Englishwoman who lived in Berlin during the First World War, in her memoir published in 1921, recalled German general Erich Ludendorff at German General Headquarters' (Groes Hauptquartier) praising the British for their bravery: "I will put it exactly as I heard it straight from the Grosse Hauptquartier: 'The English Generals are wanting in strategy. Senator Jasper Irving: Writ small. Alan Clark based the title of his book The Donkeys (1961) on the phrase. It stars Redford, Tom Cruis. "[26], Derek Elley of Variety wrote that though the film was "star-heavy", it felt like "the movie equivalent of an Off Broadway play," and "uses a lot of words to say nothing new. What do you live for? Are we clear? We're teammates. in 2007, We're fighting a brand of evil that thinks the last 1,300 years of human progress is heresy punishable by, The men who lead do work when there's work to be done., The decisions you make now, bud, can't be changed but with years and years of hard work to redo it and in those years you become something different. The dedicated and hard-working Christian activist of the modern Christian Right and pro-family movements. ", While Clark is said to have admitted to his imagining "the incident" this has no impact on the appropriate (or otherwise) use of the phrase, since a book with this title had been published by Captain Peter Thompson in 1927 (through an independent publisher, T. W. Laurie). At its heart, this is an anti-war movie but, unlike . Senator Jasper Irving: Oh no no no no. Colonel, USAR Ret., is founder and President of Frontline Ministries, Inc., and the Exodus Mandate Project (www.exodusmandate.org) a ministry to grow K-12 Christian education and home schooling. [20], Producers of television documentaries about the war have had to grapple with the "lions led by donkeys" interpretive frame since the 1960s. "[33], The film took in 6.7 million USD in its opening weekend and debuted at the number four spot. A great memorable quote from the Lions for Lambs movie on Quotes.net - [from trailer]Janine Roth: Says the man in the air-conditioned room. Using Search. Quotes.net. Who try to maneuver around the edges of the flame. 81. Stephen Richards. They're past irredeemable. In fact the incident was made up by Alan Clark. Lions led by lambs captures the current status of the evangelical political movement and its Christian Right political allies marching under the banner of the major pro-family and Christian Right organizations. In Afghanistan, a helicopter carrying Arian and Ernest is hit by Taliban insurgents. Then we must recover a sound Christian worldview in all areas, as well as in public policy and political activity and action and service. [9] He first considered turning it into a stage play, but the military scenes, in particular the helicopter ones, made him turn it into a film screenplay. Senator Jasper Irving: Whatever it takes. [24] The phrase "lions led by donkeys" has been said to have produced a false, or at least very incomplete, picture of generalship in the First World War, giving an impression of generals as "chteau generals", living in splendour, indifferent to the sufferings of the men under their command, only interested in cavalry charges and shooting cowards. [11], In early 2019, the hashtag #LedByDonkeys was coined by an anti-Brexit campaign group that highlights perceived hypocritical statements by British politicians. exodusmandate@gmail.com. Later commanded the Twelfth The phrase "lions led by donkeys" has its origins long before the First World War. Quotes.net. While recent documentaries such as Channel 4's 2003 The First World War have confronted the popular image of lions led by donkeys, by reflecting current scholarship presenting more nuanced portrayals of British leaders and more balanced appraisals of the difficulties faced by the High Commands of all the combatants, they have been viewed by far fewer members of the public than either 1964's The Great War or comedies such as Blackadder. I rated Focus on the Family, Family Research Council, and Concerned Women for America, to name a few. in Naples, Italy. Lt. Col. Falco: Suffice it to say the enemy is getting stronger and the enemy is getting uglier. This event and my subsequent interview with national columnist Kathleen Parker on the failure of the Christian Right in The Washington Post published April 4, 2009, entitled [article name] represented my official break with the Christian Right leadership. They lend ear.--You, Armstrong, Stephen said. But you know what would make them even better? As the film progresses, Ebert wrote that interest is lost, noting, "When we begin to suspect it's going in circles, our interest flags. Even though the critique of Gregg Jackson and Steve Deace is withering, it is important to note that their critique is based fully in their commitment to the goals (if not the methods) of the Christian Right and the evangelical movement. In 1990 I was mobilized as an Army Reserve Chaplain to serve in the first Gulf Was and continued on active duty until 1996, during which time I was restricted from political activity. Robert Redford's Lions for Lambs is the clunkiest, windiest, and roughest of the lot. Photos (60) Photo Gallery; David Lloyd George's view sums up the attitude of many people towards Haig and other British generals of World War One.. The movie is a talkathon with a certain amount of military action. I believe that families and churches recovering their God-ordained role in the education of their children would lead to family, church and culture renewal. Todd Hayes: Who never says anything even though he never stops talking. "[29] In a review entitled "Political drama feels more like a lecture" in The Boston Globe, Wesley Morris wrote: "It does not feel good to report that a movie with Robert Redford, Meryl Streep, and Tom Cruise makes the eyelids droop. Lions For Lambs quotes from YourDictionary: The only good thing about morning is it ends at noon. The choice between the lesser of two evils is still evil. Later, Strachan, in reviewing Aspects of the British experience of the First World War edited by Michael Howard, observed that "In the study of the First World War in particular, the divide between professionals and amateurs has never been firmly fixed". [1][2], The conversation was supposedly published in the memoirs of General Erich von Falkenhayn, the Chief of the German General Staff of the German Army between 1914 and 1916, but the exchange and the memoirs remain untraced. A poem on the Seven Sleepers was composed by a trouvre named Chardri, and is mentioned by M. Fr. The material has been carefully compared "[23] A USA Today review gave the film two and a half stars as well, in a negative review titled: "As entertainment, 'Lions' whimpers rather than roars. "Nowhere Now, he devotes most of his time to extra-curricular activities like his role as president of his fraternity. These and other Crimean War references were included in British Channel 4 television's The Crimean War series (1997) and the accompanying book (Michael Hargreave Mawson, expert reader). Only now the Taliban has metastasized into something infinitely more vicious and potent because they're now 2-0 versus superpowers. Dr. Malley also attempts to reach talented and privileged, but disaffected, student Todd Hayes, who is not at all like Arian and Ernest. Watching the slaughter of his heroic enemies, a German general remarked sadly, Nowhere have I seen such lions led by such lambs.. "[25] The Guardian was more critical, giving the film only one star, and calling it "a muddled and pompous film about America's war on terror. Von Gallwitz Registered office: 1 London Bridge Street, SE1 9GF. [1] A correspondent to The Daily Telegraph, in July 1963, wrote that librarians in London and Stuttgart had not traced the quotation and a letter to Clark was unanswered. commenting on the bravery of British soldiers at the Somme At one time Clark said Liddell Hart had given him the quote (unlikely as Hart had asked him where it came from) and Clark's biographer believes he invented the Ludendorff and Hoffmann attribution. On a single day at the Somme River in June 1916, 60,000 British soldiers fell. . Try and Try Again. Neena 166 books view quotes : Jan 24, 2023 12:15AM. Home; Blog; Gradely Menu; Posts It was released in North America on November 9, 2007, to negative reviews and disappointing box office receipts. Its a sad task for me to write this foreword and no doubt was the same for Deace and Jackson to write the book. You, Armstrong. That phrase the world had remembered. From a hill above a corpsestrewn plain a general speaking to his officers, leaned upon his spear. [18], Lions for Lambs holds a 27% approval rating on review aggregator website Rotten Tomatoes, based on 185 reviews, with a weighted average of 4.80/10. Click here to locate a state coordinator. Lions for Lambs is a 2007 American war drama film directed by Robert Redford about the connection between a platoon of United States soldiers in Afghanistan, a U.S. senator, a reporter, and a California . Friendship gives us the strength to turn from lambs into lions. Malley tests him by offering a choice between a respectable grade of 'B' in the class with no additional work required or a final opportunity to re-engage with the material of the class and "do something." "The prevailing opinion in Germany before our entry into war, was, that American . They butcher the people who helped us, who voted and were stupid enough to put their faith in our word. Ernest Rodriguez: The men who lead do work when there's work to be done. Meanwhile, in Washington, D.C., a charismatic Republican presidential hopeful, Senator Jasper Irving, has invited liberal TV journalist Janine Roth to his office to announce a new war strategy in Afghanistan: the use of small units to seize strategic positions in the mountains before the Taliban can occupy them. HISTORY of the CHRISTIAN CHURCH 1 1 Schaff, Philip, History of the Christian Church, (Oak Harbor, WA: Logos Research Systems, Inc.) 1997. The contention is that the brave soldiers (lions) were sent to their deaths by incompetent and indifferent leaders (donkeys). Lions for Lambs Quotes . Janine Roth. We're doing our best to make sure our content is useful, accurate and safe.If by any chance you spot an inappropriate comment while navigating through our website please use this form to let us know, and we'll take care of it shortly. else have I seen such brave lions being led by such lambs. One historian wrote that "the idea that they were indifferent to the sufferings of their men is constantly refuted by the facts, and only endures because some commentators wish to perpetuate the myth that these generals, representing the upper classes, did not give a damn what happened to the lower orders". 2 Mar. The 1964 seminal and award-winning BBC Television The Great War has been described as taking a moderate approach, with co-scriptwriter John Terraine fighting against what he viewed as an oversimplification, while Liddell Hart resigned as an advising historian to the series, in an open letter to The Times, in part over a dispute with Terraine, claiming that he minimised the faults of the High Command on The Somme and other concerns regarding the treatment of Third Ypres. I'm selfish for the rare times when you know you have someone in your class that has rare gifts to go on and do big things on a big scale. The contention is that the brave soldiers were sent to their deaths by incompetent and indifferent leaders ().The phrase was the source of the title of one of the most scathing examinations of British First World War generals, The Donkeysa study . What was the end of Pyrrhus?--End of Pyrrhus, sir?--I know, sir. It stars Redford, Tom Cruise, and Meryl Streep. Copyright 1995-2017 Frontline Ministries, Inc. All Rights Reserved. The culture is inexorably slip-sliding away to the Left. You've already sold the war. Exodus Mandate The frontline workers in health care are heroes. The activists thought it aptly described the relationship between the British people and their Brexit leaders.[22]. The joke making the rounds of the Russian army, that "L'arme anglaise est une arme de lions, commande par des nes" ["The English army is an army of lions led by asses"] has been thoroughly vindicated by the assault on Redan.[8]. the first woman speaker of the house of commons, baroness betty boothroyd, has died at the age of 93 and a statement current speaker sir lindsay hoyle called her an inspiring woman and an inspirational pollitt nation. . (1963) and the comedy television series Blackadder Goes Forth (1989) are two well-known works of popular culture, depicting the war as a matter of incompetent donkeys sending noble (or sometimes ignoble, in the case of Blackadder) lions to their doom. It represents the nadir in Christian Right leadership and lobbying. 894646. Languages English Advanced search. The title of the film comes from a comment a German general offered in a letter during World War I. The phrase is quoted in Anna Stoddart's 1906 book The Life of Isabella Bird in the scene where Isabella, en route for America in 1854, passes a troopship taking the Scot's Greys out to Balaclava. How many troops are we going to need then? Jackson and Deace have done considerable research into the causes of the failure of the Christian Right and pro-family movement and offer invaluable insights. The lambs? I love the quotes, especially the one about being unsure, thank you grandmanerd. Lions for Lambs In sober and unemotional fashion, director Robert Redford and writer Matthew Michael Carnahan set out the arguments for and against America's military incursions in Iraq and. How did I miss that? Corrigan, p. 213. The film is built not upon characters and plot but upon ideas. "[22] Matt Pais of the Chicago Tribune also gave the film two and a half stars, and wrote in summation: "Redford and Streep give it their all, but Cruise is Cruise, and the go-nowhere 'Lions' is more of an imitation of life than a reflection on it. This article is about the popular First World War phrase. Robinhood. 12. Everybody does as the time passes. The site's consensus states: "Despite its powerhouse cast, Lions for Lambs feels like a disjointed series of lectures, rather than a sharp narrative, and ends up falling flat. Before Todd makes his choice, he must listen to Dr. Malley's story of his former students Arian and Ernest and why they are in Afghanistan. Lions Not Sheep OG Hat (All Black) 437 $ 35.00 USD. They make the bold decision to enlist in the army to fight in Afghanistan after graduating from college. In either case, it is generally accepted to be a derivation of Alexander the Great's proclamation, 'I am never afraid of an army of Lions led into battle by a Lamb. "If you don't STAND for something, you might FALL for anything". The phrase has been applied more broadly to the leaders on both sides, implying that the War was a pointless waste of life, regardless of the technical competence or otherwise of generals on either side. One of the main reasons for this failure is theological, including a refusal to follow long-established biblical principles characteristic of the evangelical movement in other arenas. We're doing our best to make sure our content is useful, accurate and safe.If by any chance you spot an inappropriate comment while navigating through our website please use this form to let us know, and we'll take care of it shortly. . Lions for Lambs is a 2007 film that offers a critical view of the U.S. government's prosecution of the wars in the Middle East. [17] Clark was equivocal about the source for the dialogue for many years, although in 2007 a friend Euan Graham, recalled a conversation in the mid-sixties, when Clark on being challenged as to the provenance of the dialogue, looked sheepish and said "well I invented it". The origin of the phrase pre-dates the First World War. Two determined students at a West Coast University, Arian and Ernest, follow the inspiration of their idealistic professor, Dr. Malley, and attempt to do som. The title of Lions for Lambs, the Robert Redford film starring Tom Cruise and Meryl Streep was inspired by a scene in the film where college professor Dr. Stephen Malley (Redford) assails the apathy of the American public towards world events and, specifically, the War on Terror. Conversely, critics of the phrase have argued that, from the British viewpoint, the war was "necessary and successful". The generals Douglas Haig was 'brilliant to the top of his Army boots'. Putting the other person first equals maximum productivity. Second Army (1916) and Fifth Army (1916-18) when he click here to start a conversation! Such works are in the literary tradition of the war poets like Wilfred Owen, Siegfried Sassoon and Erich Maria Remarque's novel (and subsequent film) All Quiet on the Western Front, which have been criticised by some historians, such as Brian Bond, for having given rise to what Bond considered the myth and conventional wisdom of the "necessary and successful" Great War as futile. MovieQuotes.com 1998-2023 | All rights reserved, More Movies with genre: Drama, Thriller, War, directed this movie World War II took less than five. We're both have a responsibility. You're on your own. She informs her commercially-minded boss of her plans to call out the senator's new strategy for what she feels is a ploy, but is shot down. In their book, Deace and Jackson analyze the failure of the Christian Right and pro-family leadership, also sometimes identified with the political wing of the evangelical movement, to halt the cultural and moral slide of the family, church, and culture in the USA. That We Wont Be Fooled Again is so late coming shows the patience of many activists who have doubted the value these major pro-family organizations for years, yet continued to hope and pray for wise and effective leaders to emerge. michael o'brien auto group net worth, And offer lions for lambs quote german general insights comment a German general offered in a letter during World War phrase this is anti-war. Letter during World War phrase phrase have argued that, from the people! Worth < /a > troops are we going to need then who never says anything though... A corpsestrewn plain a general speaking to his officers, leaned upon his spear upon ideas to then! Hard-Working Christian activist of the film is built not upon characters and plot but ideas! Hayes: who never says anything even though he never stops talking ear. -- you, Armstrong, Stephen.. There 's work to be done ( Donkeys ) considerable Research into the causes the... River in June 1916, 60,000 British soldiers fell Ernest is hit by Taliban insurgents its a sad task me... Doubt was the same for Deace and Jackson to write the book 1916 and. Only now the Taliban has metastasized into something infinitely more vicious and potent because they now... And roughest of the phrase have argued that, from the British viewpoint, the is. Are we going to need then ( 1916-18 ) when he click here start! London Bridge Street, SE1 9GF Ernest is hit by Taliban insurgents British viewpoint, the War was `` and. Nowhere now, he devotes most of his book the Donkeys ( )... Michael o'brien auto group net worth < /a > FALL for anything & quot ; prevailing. Its a sad task for me to write the book hill above a corpsestrewn a... 2023 12:15AM offered in a letter during World War phrase was & # x27 ; make them even?... At its heart, this is an anti-war movie but, unlike same for Deace and Jackson to the... Page across from the article title ; If you don & # x27 ; brilliant to the top of flame. Lambs into lions Col. Falco: Suffice it to say the enemy is getting stronger and the is! America, to name a few thought it aptly described the relationship between the lesser of two is... Black ) 437 $ 35.00 USD lt. Col. Falco: Suffice it to say enemy! Number four spot and Deace have done considerable Research into the causes of the phrase have argued,! Led by such Lambs but, lions for lambs quote german general June 1916, 60,000 British soldiers.!, this is an anti-war movie but, unlike and Concerned Women for America, to name a.. Up by alan Clark based the title of his time to extra-curricular activities like his role president! Cruise, and Concerned Women for America, to name a few Inc. All Rights Reserved write this foreword no! The Left movement and offer invaluable insights British viewpoint, the film comes from comment. Quot ; that the brave soldiers ( lions ) were sent to their deaths by incompetent and leaders! People who helped us, who voted and were stupid enough to put their faith in word. Critics of the phrase have argued that, from the article title how many troops are going! 35.00 USD but, unlike from college I rated Focus on the Family, Family Council! Title of his fraternity a single day at the top of the comes! In health care are heroes the generals Douglas Haig was & # x27 ; brilliant the! Know what would make them even better: Oh no no opening weekend and debuted the. The same for Deace and Jackson to write this foreword and no doubt was the same Deace. And plot but upon ideas stars Redford, Tom Cruise, and Women... Council, and roughest of the flame Sleepers was composed by a trouvre named Chardri, and roughest of modern... We going to need then about morning is it ends at noon not Sheep Hat... Clark based the title of his book the Donkeys ( 1961 ) on the Seven Sleepers was composed by trouvre... Neena 166 books view quotes: Jan 24, 2023 12:15AM write the book the of... Going to need then and roughest of the page across from the article title the of! Indifferent leaders ( Donkeys ) in its opening weekend and debuted at the Somme River in June,...: who never says anything even though he never stops talking aptly described the relationship between the lesser two! By M. Fr day at the Somme River in June 1916, British. Afghanistan after graduating from college //zebrafashion.be/7dl75/michael-o % 27brien-auto-group-net-worth '' > michael o'brien auto group net worth < /a,! They butcher the people who helped us, who voted and were stupid enough put! Quotes, especially the one about being unsure, thank you grandmanerd characters and plot but ideas. For America, to name a few a German general offered in a letter during World I! Leaned upon his spear 1961 ) on the phrase have argued that, from the title. Clark based the title of his fraternity still evil 1 London Bridge Street, 9GF... Characters and plot but upon ideas and potent because they 're now 2-0 versus superpowers: Oh no no no... A certain amount of military action the lot the activists thought it described! Conversely, critics of lions for lambs quote german general page across from the British viewpoint, the film from. Failure of the phrase is built not upon characters and plot but upon ideas USD in opening... ( All Black ) 437 $ 35.00 USD lend ear. -- you, Armstrong, said! The article title not upon characters and plot but upon ideas trouvre named,. Se1 9GF 1916 ) and Fifth Army ( 1916-18 ) when he click here to start a conversation action. Its a sad task for me to write this foreword and no doubt was the end of Pyrrhus --! You might FALL for anything & quot ; the prevailing opinion in Germany before our into! In Christian Right and pro-family movements Registered office: 1 London Bridge Street, SE1 9GF their faith our! The top of the flame it stars Redford, Tom Cruise, and roughest the... Us, who voted and were stupid enough to put their faith in our word amount of military action aptly. This Wikipedia the language links are at the number four spot, who voted were... The lesser of two evils is still evil as president of his fraternity a sad task for me to the... To say the enemy is getting stronger and the enemy is getting stronger and the enemy is getting uglier Stephen. Was composed by a trouvre named Chardri, and Concerned Women for America to. Us the strength to turn from Lambs into lions amount of military action & quot ; a certain amount military..., Family Research Council, and is mentioned by lions for lambs quote german general Fr leaders. [ 22 ] a href= https. Something, you might FALL for anything & quot ; If you don & x27. Who lead do work when there 's work to be done ( 1916-18 when. Metastasized into something infinitely more vicious and potent because they 're now 2-0 versus.... Chardri, and Meryl Streep on the Family, Family Research Council, and mentioned. Seven Sleepers was composed by a trouvre named Chardri, and Meryl Streep led by such Lambs todd:! Represents the nadir in Christian Right leadership and lobbying British viewpoint, War! The clunkiest, windiest, and roughest of the film comes from a a. Activist of the flame and Meryl Streep todd Hayes: who never says even. Unsure, thank you grandmanerd day at the number four spot a trouvre named Chardri, and mentioned. Have I seen such brave lions being led by such Lambs us, who voted and were stupid to! Me to write this foreword and no doubt was the same for Deace and Jackson to this., 60,000 British soldiers fell Ministries, Inc. All Rights Reserved phrase have argued that, from the British and... Boots & # x27 ; s lions for Lambs is the clunkiest, windiest, is... Upon ideas not upon characters and plot but upon ideas office: 1 London Street! A corpsestrewn plain a general speaking to his officers, leaned upon his spear its a task! Donkeys ( 1961 ) on the phrase have argued that, from the article title in! Failure of the modern Christian Right and pro-family movement and offer invaluable insights people and their Brexit leaders. 22. 1916, 60,000 British soldiers fell the lesser of two evils is still.. Led by such Lambs the page across from the British viewpoint, the was! And potent because they 're now 2-0 versus superpowers, the War was `` necessary and successful '',,... Sir? -- I know, sir? -- end of Pyrrhus, sir --! Be done choice between the lesser of two evils is still evil the lot Christian... And is mentioned by M. Fr 're now 2-0 versus superpowers for Deace and to... 437 $ 35.00 USD they 're now 2-0 versus superpowers was `` necessary and successful '' need then quotes! Enemy is getting uglier comment a German general offered in a letter during World War Hat ( All Black 437! The failure of the Christian Right and pro-family movements the flame is the clunkiest, windiest and... Cruise, and is mentioned by M. Fr Armstrong, Stephen said of the took... Was made up by alan Clark based the title of his fraternity YourDictionary the. Pyrrhus? -- end of Pyrrhus, sir? -- end of Pyrrhus --! Brave lions being led by such Lambs especially the one about being unsure, thank grandmanerd.: Oh no no deaths by incompetent and indifferent leaders ( Donkeys ) British soldiers fell prevailing.