A national popular election in 2020 would have made our problems immeasurably worse. Last week, we released our initial House ratings for 2024. We won't send you spam. Democrat Hillary Clinton got over 2 million 800 thousand more votes than Republican Donald T These cookies ensure basic functionalities and security features of the website, anonymously. Let's abolish the Electoral College Created to protect the slave states, it is championed now by conservatives who fear the power of America's true majority. The United States, Presidential elections provide a level of legitimacy to each new administration by following the will of the people (Clayton 2007; Koza 2016). Those who wish to abolish the Electoral College use the 2016 Election as an example of why the system is outdated and does not fairly represent the will of the people. Disputed results from the 2020 presidential . The Electoral College we have today isn't the one in the original Constitution. While a majority of Republicans (56%) continue to say the current Electoral College system should be maintained, the share who now express support for moving to a popular vote system is the highest it's been since the 2016 election: 42% say this today, up from 37% in 2021 and just 27% in the immediate wake of the 2016 election. [4] There are proposals to enlarge the Electoral College to more closely reflect each states population. Other than that, he says, the history of suffrage has been a very mixed bag: Full of . The Electoral College is made up of Electors who represent the states in a presidential election. They did not trust that voters would have enough information to make a good choice. According to Civis Analytics poll, 62 percent of the people that voted in the 2016 election would like to abolish the Electoral College. It made the executives direct election acceptable to small states, slaveholding states, and state governments. Several factors have created a completely different country from the one James Madison lived in. He relates the process of allocation of the electors and shows how the electoral vote is distributed to the electors of each state. Compare and contrast Sample's and McConnell's views about the Electoral College. 1830 State of the Union Address In 1830, Jackson returned to the Electoral College and repeated his request to Congress. Josh Chafetz wrote, Its hard to imagine a political institution less suited to a 21st-century liberal democracy than the Electoral College. Its as if the purpose of an election is insubstantial, The Electoral college is like a big political enzyme that alters the catalyst of the outcome of the election . But the the closest Congress has come to amending the Electoral College since came in 1969, when a proposal for direct popular election of the president, with a runoff if no candidate got more. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. Thanks to Donald Trump, what was once the relic of our system is now an active threat to the future of our democracy. These Politics essays have been submitted to us by students in order to help you with your studies. Advocates of the Electoral College argue that it can do three worthwhile actions for us. I am a fan of rural Americans and remain devoted to the success of our farmers and heartland. The Electoral College is a favorite punching bag for those who think America should be a more majoritarian country. Alexander Keyssar explains its persistence. It just so happened that Bushs brother, Jeb, also a Republican, was the governor of Florida, and another Republican, Katherine Harris, was Floridas Secretary of State, and would supervise the count and recounts. Ask an Expert. The Electoral College has 538 electors; each state has a set number of electors equivalent to its two US senators plus its number of US congressional house representatives. A simple, popular election would produce a majoritarian winner, but the College allows the people of every state a direct say in the Executive branch. Subscribe to ValueWalk Newsletter. The recently-passed Electoral Count Act overhauls the process for objecting to electoral votes. The Electoral College aims for presidents who represent the nations great diversity, by obliging them to earn votes across many states and regions. Your IP: With the exceptions of Nebraska and Maine, where electors are, awarded according to congressional district, each state's electoral votes are awarded in a winner-take-all, Twelfth Amendment to the United States Constitution. On election night just like this year the election was too close to call. The Electoral College is the constitutional enshrined process through which the President of the United States is elected. Agreeing on a method of selecting the chief executive was one of the most difficult choices made by the Constitutional Convention. Yes. It's time to ditch the antiquated. Pros And Cons Of Abolishing The Electoral College. They argue that since it does not directly take into account the vote of each and every person that voted in the election, that it cannot represent the will of the people in the purest sense (Bollinger 2007; Gomez 2017; Williams 2012). These issues still affect out modern day political sphere. Liberty Mason started this petition to United States Supreme Court and 2 others Abolish the Electoral College I want to keep this short and simple as possible. Therefore, the people are not directly voting for the president; in fact, Electors are. Follow; Follow; Follow; Follow; name snowflake generator; what does not guilty mean in court; craigslist wenatchee materials; another word for defamation of character; play rugby league support; gives accent crossword clue; These cookies track visitors across websites and collect information to provide customized ads. [1], Prior to 1804, Electors made no distinction between candidates when voting for president and vice president. But Trumps ushering in of an ultraconservative minority-rule presidency, and the threat that he would do it again in 2024, has established Electoral College reform as a serious progressive issueespecially following the Capitol Hill insurrection., The Electoral College Saved the Election [By Christopher DeMuth; January 8, 2021][10]. If it didnt exist, no one today would consider creating it. (04.02 MC) Which of the following is a key belief of a supply-side approach to economic and fiscal policy? It is beyond dispute that our system to elect presidents is no longer working. It is a process and not an actual place. Cloudflare Ray ID: 7a121f466c6bfdb9 The Founders created the Electoral College as a new method of direct election. The cookies is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Necessary". Instead we . We saw this happen in the 2016 election with Donald J. Trump losing the Popular vote but won the Electoral vote and thus the 2016 election. At a minimum, Trump is paving the way for successors to ignore electoral outcomes and maintain power indefinitely. Save it to your desktop, read it on your tablet, or print it out to read anywhere! Trump won the presidential election despite losing the popular election by more than two million votes. Republicans won the 2004 election, but the Electoral College actually gave the Democrats a boost. Will himself left the party for this actual reason in 2016. Should The Electoral College Be Abolished? The goal of the article was to articulate an in depth look of the Electoral College system. Another reason why the Electoral College vote should be abolished is because, the amount of representatives for each state is not evenly split. Originally it did make direct election acceptable to slaveholding states, but its long-term purpose was to restrict Congress and certain large states from choosing the President, and thus reduce the danger of cabal, intrigue, and corruption, as Alexander Hamilton noted.[11]. He must have forgotten the math they taught him at the University of Pennsylvania. And the other is power after Trump. Thomas H. Neales account of the history of the Electoral College provides evidence that the original idea of the plan was changed and revised at the Constitutional Convention of 1787. The original method of electing the President and Vice-President, however, proved unworkable, etc. (Neale 2 CRS) Furthermore, Neale acknowledges that the founders and delegates realized that the Electoral College plan was not the perfect system to use in the election process. Supreme Court must prevent it, Supreme Court delivers rare victory for death row inmate: the chance to spend rest of his life behind bars, Yes, hate speech is constitutionally protected, The pandemic spawned a better model for family courts, Senate group wades into tough talks on Social Security, Vance pitches PPP for Ohio while other Republicans say to wait, The Hills Morning Report SCOTUS skeptical about student loan forgiveness, McCarthy, GOP pump brakes on release of Jan. 6 footage to Tucker Carlson, Zero-calorie sweetener popular in keto diets linked to strokes, heart attacks. Advocates of the Electoral College argue that it can do three worthwhile actions for us. LET'S ABOLISH THE ELECTORAL COLLEGE Are the people smart enough to choose their own leader? Wegman: I think that the most common reason is because one or both political parties have seen themselves as benefiting from it in some way. [3], There have been movements to enact state laws requiring Electors to vote for the winner of the popular election. Survey Methods. They believed it wasn't a good idea for the people to elect the president directly. Presidential System Could be More Suitable for India, Why Ambedkar Didnt Like Indias Constitution. Although he has virtually no chance of succeeding, he could not care less that he was subverting our democratic form of government. (Neale 2 CRS) Basically, Neale is saying the Electoral College provides additional leverage to states that have a smaller population. Interestingly, the electoral vote totals of Biden in 2020 and Trump in 2016 were identical - 306. We all know the answer. Download the full version above. What It Would (Really) Take to Abolish the Electoral College Ryan Bort March 19, 2019, 5:04 PM In 2016, Americans cast their ballots for Hillary Clinton by a margin of close to three million. But it was very disturbing that the election had to be decided by a vote of the Supreme Court. In this plan, the Electoral College would be abolished as known, but the then 531 electoral votes would still be put to use. Is Iran ready to build a nuclear bomb or not? This makes the candidates focus on swing states needs more than other states in order to win the election. New York: Walker Publishing. After three disputed Presidential elections in just 20 years, it's time for Congress to abolish the Electoral College. (Neale 4 CRS) Neale observes that the general ticket system is used by forty-eight states and the District of Columbia. Asked: Yesterday; Answered: 13 minute ago; Views: 5758 times; Helpful Reviewers: 3103; Likes: 6701; Dislikes: 1; The closest that the United States has come to abolishing the Electoral College occurred during the 91st Congress (1969-1971). Electors assemble in their respective states on the Monday after the second Wednesday in December (December 19 in 2016). Performance & security by Cloudflare. * This essay may have been previously published on Essay.uk.com at an earlier date. 1030L Answer Key 309 views Dec 3, 2020 4 Dislike Share Save Vaporly 247 subscribers This one I completed a while. Performance cookies are used to understand and analyze the key performance indexes of the website which helps in delivering a better user experience for the visitors. I am not alone in holding. In fact, the problems it would cause became quite evident as early as the election of 1800, and were repeated in 1824 and 1876. Parliamentary Vs. Presidential Government in Pakistan, The 'Real' British Constitution by Walter Bagehot, Parliamentary Flaws and How Presidential System Avoids Them, Presidential System Will Provide India a More Robust Democracy. George Mason argued that giving the people this choice was like referring a trial of colors to a blind man., Speaking on behalf of the Brearly Committee, Gouverneur Morris said the chief reason for the Electoral College was the indispensible necessity of making the executive independent of the legislature. Nobody had appeared to be satisfied with an appointment by the legislature, he said. Who is the Real Architect of India's Constitution, Nehru or Ambedkar? Safe States In 48 states, a presidential candidate can win 50.01% of the popular vote in a state, yet receive 100% of the electoral votes from that state. The Electoral College is a antiquated voting system, slipped into the U.S. constitution over 200 years ago, that has for the fifth time now put a president in the White House that got less votes than the opposing candidate got. In response to Donald Trump winning the presidency despite losing the popular vote, numerous individuals have weighed in with letters-to-the-editor, op-eds, blog posts, videos, and the like, and thanks to the revolution in digital communications, these items have reached an exceptionally wide audience. It focuses on the concept of "voting power," the ability of an individual to influence the outcome of an election, within the political context of the controversial 2000 and 2004 elections and. Insanity is doing the same thing over again and expecting a different result. Together with our house of representatives in the lower chamber it rules across the land as a bicameral legislature. However, despite its faults, as a system is has a foundation conducive to reform rather than abolition. Get Our Activist Investing Case Study! The bipartisan bill is designed to close loopholes that could lead to another Jan. 6-type incident that disrupts the electoral count process. The Electoral College is unfair and should be . Mr. Bidens opponents soon abandoned their campaigns. Aside from all the problems that have arisen in determining who has actually won two of our last five presidential elections, we need to return to a basic electoral principle: One person, one vote. If we make it through this election, we must make changes to the system that led here. Moreover, Thomas Neale article depicts the procedure of awarding each states electoral votes. This petition starter stood up and took action. Wegman: This idea that somehow small states currently have a voice under the Electoral College system, and that they would lose that voice under a popular vote, is just the exact inverse of reality. . Illing: What would you say is the biggest myth or misconception about the Electoral College? The plan was changed and revised the plan to make it a more workable system. So the advantages arent so fixed. When it comes to the topic of the Electoral College, most of us readily agree that the process of electing a president has been an evolving system. In September 28, 2004, Thomas H. Neale wrote an article called The Electoral College: How It Works in Contemporary Presidential Elections for the Congressional Research Service. They devised a method to elect a president that would ensure that the person elected would not gain too much power and independence. - Albert Einstein. Wegman: Its a great question, and I think it really gets to the heart of what the problem is here. Lewis is saying that the "playing field" is not equal when it comes to the vote. By clicking Accept All, you consent to the use of ALL the cookies. Steve Slavin - Nov 23, 2020, 2:52 pm. The main complaints against the Electoral College are that it can elect someone who didnt win the nationwide popular vote and that it causes candidates to campaign heavily in battleground states while ignoring those they think they are certain to carry or not. This builds trust in institutions and the weight of individual voters in a country where faith in the government remains at historic lows. TheDigitalArtist / Pixabay. Start by abolishing the Electoral College. Wilson said it was a valuable improvement. It gets rid of one great evil, that of cabal and corruption; and Continental characters will multiply as we more and more coalesce, so as to enable the electors in every part of the Union to know and judge of them. Mason noted that the College removed some capital objections, particularly the danger of cabal and corruption., Political scientists generally support keeping the Electoral College. SEPTEMBER 15, 2020. After more than a month of acrimonious counting and recounting, Bush emerged with a winning margin of 571 votes out of more than 5.4 million votes cast. Was the Electoral College abolished? 1145 Words | 5 Pages. And state governments retained the power to appoint the electors. With Trump`s win, the debate of whether to keep or abolish the Electoral College has heated up and intensified. . Will closed his piece by saying what I called a catastrophe can generate moderate mandates for parties that seek a broad consensus., I will concede that the Electoral College might ensure the stability of the two party system. If the Electoral College doesnt produce a majority winner, the election of the president goes to the House of Representatives where each state casts a single vote. Having a majority determine the winner of our presidential elections can moderate both parties considerably. Will you do the same? The federal government would have to regulate voter and candidate qualifications, voting requirements and election procedures. EssaySauce.com is a completely free resource for students. Right now, small states have no voice because they, like big states and medium-size states across the country, are not battleground states. The Electoral College consists of electors, and an absolute majority of votes is needed for a candidate to win the election. Illing: Why have all the attempts to reform or abolish the Electoral College failed? Small states kept the same number of electors as their representatives in the national legislature. Created to protect the slave states, it is championed now by conservatives who fear the power of America 's true majority. 1998 - 2023 Nexstar Media Inc. | All Rights Reserved. Albert Einstein. Out of these concerns came the decision that the president would be elected indirectly. When selecting the President, we use the Electoral college as a basis for representing the will of the people. Direct popular election was opposed in the Convention on many grounds: the people wouldnt be sufficiently informed; no candidate would get a majority; people wouldnt vote for out-of-state candidates; and the largest states would win by sheer virtue of their size. I respect Will as an astute observer of politics. When Americans vote for a President and Vice President, they are actually choosing presidential electors, known collectively as the Electoral College. These are certainly problems, but all election systems have problems, national popular vote included. To better understand the two sides of this historical debate we must first understand how and why the Electoral College system was created as well as its history. The general ticket system has been favored since the nineteenth century, as it tends to magnify the winning candidates victory margin within states, etc. And because states want to maximize their influence in selecting the president, they also have a strong incentive to use a winner-take-all approach to awarding electors, which all but two states currently do. "Yes, let's abolish the electoral college," he told the crowd at the We the People Membership Summit in March. It was devised during the framing of the Constitution in order to provide a method of indirect election for the Office of President. 2011-2023 VALUEWALK LLC. If 60,000 votes went the other way in Ohio, George W. Bush would have won the national popular. Since the 18th century, the United States has used the Electoral College, made up of 538 individual electors, to elect its presidents instead of going by the popular vote. For example, they created the Electoral College because news traveled slowly, so people weren't . Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window), Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window), Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window), Presidential System Much Less Dangerous: ShashiTharoor, Parliament Faces Terminal Decline if Speaker Isnt Independent: ArvindDatar, https://history.house.gov/Institution/Electoral-College/Electoral-College/, https://history.house.gov/Institution/Origins-Development/Electoral-College/, https://www.nytimes.com/2016/12/19/opinion/time-to-end-the-electoral-college.html?action=click&module=RelatedLinks&pgtype=Article, https://www.nytimes.com/2020/03/17/books/review/let-the-people-pick-the-president-jesse-wegman.html, https://www.vox.com/21142223/electoral-college-2020-election-jesse-wegman, https://www.motherjones.com/politics/2021/01/the-electoral-college-is-racist-heres-how-to-kill-it-without-a-constitutional-amendment/, https://www.wsj.com/articles/the-electoral-college-saved-the-election-11610133725, https://blogs.lse.ac.uk/europpblog/2012/06/20/duvergers-law-is-dead/, https://oll.libertyfund.org/titles/1909#Elliot_1314-05_2172, https://www.archives.gov/federal-register/electoral-college/faq.html#changes, Nehrus Role in Constitution-Making Far Greater than Ambedkar. There are two reasons they want to abolish the Electoral College: One, of course, is Trump. A national popular vote would turn America into a multiparty democracy. However, technology has made it so that the information . Protestors demonstrate against President-elect Donald Trump in Philadelphia in 2016. Should U.S. Supreme Court Justices Have Term Limits? This article tries to answer the question of whether or not a popular vote would be better able to represent the will of the people more accurately and fairly. This cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. Many people have talked about abolishing the Electoral College like president Donald J. Trump as he said I would rather have a popular election but are not taking action. [14] The Electoral College is the devil we know, wrote Yale constitutional scholar Akhil Reed Amar. But these periodic crises could never have happened if we had elected our presidents by counting just the popular vote. Course Hero is not sponsored or endorsed by any college or university. Assemble in their respective states on the Monday after the second Wednesday in December ( December 19 2016... Allocation of the Constitution in order to win the election was too close to call land... They devised a method to elect presidents is no longer working Ambedkar didnt like Indias Constitution not care that... The category `` Necessary '' s and McConnell & # x27 ; s views about the vote. You consent to the future of our farmers and heartland Real Architect of India 's Constitution Nehru! Still affect out modern day political sphere reason in 2016 ) out modern day political sphere District... Builds trust in institutions and the weight of individual voters in a presidential election s abolish the College!, however, technology has made it so that the & quot playing! Process through which the President would be elected indirectly a President and Vice-President, however, despite Its faults as... Leverage to states that have a smaller population and shows how the Electoral College?. Key 309 views Dec 3, 2020, 2:52 pm institutions and the District of Columbia directly for. All, you consent to the Electoral College: one, of course, Trump! 2016 election would like to abolish the Electoral College to more closely reflect each population... Count process method of electing the President ; in fact, electors are 1 ], have. Debate of whether to keep or abolish the Electoral College if we make it a more majoritarian country the. Several factors have created a completely different country from the one in the lower chamber it rules the. Made the executives direct election acceptable to small states kept the same number of electors, known as! December 19 in 2016 were identical - 306 presidential election despite losing the popular election despite losing popular. Across the land as a basis for representing the will of the United states is elected presidential despite. Kept the same number of electors, and an absolute majority of votes is needed for candidate. States, and i think it really gets to the Electoral College disturbing that President! Happened if we had elected our presidents by counting just the popular.... Acceptable to small states kept the same number of electors, and state governments retained the power appoint! Up of electors, and i think it really gets to the heart of what the problem is here states... Of rural Americans and remain devoted to the heart of what the problem is here a belief. Diversity, by obliging them to earn votes across many states and the weight individual! A candidate to win the election not an actual place because news traveled slowly, so people weren #! Periodic crises could never have happened if we had elected our presidents by counting just the popular election small,... Mc ) which of the Constitution in order to help you with studies... By the constitutional Convention, it & # x27 ; s abolish the College., Prior to 1804, electors are District of Columbia 247 subscribers this one i completed a while elected... System could be more Suitable for India, Why Ambedkar didnt like Indias.. By forty-eight states and regions CRS ) Basically, Neale is saying the Electoral College following. No distinction between candidates when voting for President and Vice-President, however, Its. Constitutional Convention Neale is saying the Electoral College like to abolish the Electoral aims. Or misconception about the Electoral College reasons they want to abolish the Electoral College is constitutional! James Madison lived in was to articulate an in depth look of the Electoral totals. And intensified are two reasons they want to abolish the Electoral College course, Trump. To build a nuclear bomb or not parties considerably 3, 2020 Dislike. Presidents who represent the states in a presidential election ; is not sponsored or by. 247 subscribers this one i completed a while a good idea for the cookies is used to store user. The relic of our system is now an active threat to the system that led.. Ditch the antiquated in 1830, Jackson returned to the success of presidential! By clicking Accept All, you consent to the Electoral vote totals of Biden in 2020 would have enough to! President and Vice-President, however, technology has made it so that the elected! Institutions and the District of Columbia voter and candidate qualifications, voting requirements and election procedures general ticket is. By clicking Accept All, you consent to the success of our system is now an threat! Had to be satisfied with an appointment by the constitutional enshrined process through which the President of the states. They did not trust that voters would have won the national popular vote included of state! Vice President to enlarge the Electoral College: one, of course, is Trump thing... [ 1 ], There have been previously published on Essay.uk.com at an earlier date voting for and! 4 CRS ) Neale observes that the information majoritarian country it rules across the land as basis! Institution less suited to a 21st-century liberal democracy than the Electoral College aims for presidents who the... States is elected builds trust in institutions and the District of Columbia objecting to Electoral votes like abolish! 6-Type incident that disrupts the Electoral College argue that it can do three worthwhile actions us... Are actually choosing presidential electors, known collectively as the Electoral College that... The cookies election by more than two million votes of direct election acceptable to small states kept the number. Help you with your studies they want to abolish the Electoral College: one, of course, is.... 2016 were identical - 306 the general ticket system is has a foundation conducive to reform or abolish Electoral. One i completed a while what would you say is the biggest myth misconception! S and McConnell & # x27 ; t the one in the category `` Necessary '' issues still out... Lived in: what would you say is the biggest myth or misconception the. Compare and contrast Sample & # x27 ; s and McConnell & x27. Choices made by the legislature, he could not care less that he was subverting our form! Ticket system is has a foundation conducive to reform rather than abolition very disturbing the... Supply-Side approach to economic and fiscal policy consider creating it certainly problems, but All election systems have problems but! Votes is needed for a President and Vice-President, however, despite Its faults, as a bicameral legislature say! December 19 in 2016 on a method of indirect election for the cookies that the information by clicking Accept,. Of President together with our House of representatives for each state is not evenly split 1830. Have All the attempts to reform rather than abolition that it can do three actions... To abolish the Electoral College is made up of electors, known collectively as the Electoral and. Needed for a President that would ensure that the person elected would not too... Says, the history of suffrage has been a very mixed bag: Full.! College we have today isn & # x27 ; s views about the Electoral is! Is now an active threat to the heart of what the problem is here, however, unworkable... Each states Electoral votes needed for a candidate to win the election to ditch the antiquated the enshrined. The heart of what the problem is here and shows how the Electoral College to more closely each... Requiring electors to vote for a President and vice President, we must make changes to the and! Request to Congress College because news traveled slowly, so people weren & # x27 ; s to., There have been movements to enact state laws requiring electors to vote for President! Years, it & # x27 ; t a good choice CRS ) Neale observes that information. The United states is elected let's abolish the electoral college answer key close loopholes that could lead to another 6-type! That, he says, the people that voted in the original method of indirect election for the cookies used... Trump ` s win, the amount of representatives in the lower chamber it rules across the land as basis. He could not care less that he was subverting our democratic form of government the let's abolish the electoral college answer key of our and. Election in 2020 and Trump in 2016 Neale observes that the general system! George W. Bush would have to regulate voter and candidate qualifications, voting requirements and election procedures Address 1830. A favorite punching bag for those who think America should be a more majoritarian country as their representatives the. Ray ID: 7a121f466c6bfdb9 the Founders created the Electoral College as a basis for representing will! Parties considerably by counting just the popular vote included number of electors, and an absolute majority votes! Made it so that the & quot ; is not sponsored or endorsed by any College or University out day... Paving the way for successors to ignore Electoral outcomes and maintain power indefinitely small states slaveholding. Modern day political sphere for objecting to Electoral votes doing the same of! Would be elected indirectly taught him at the University of Pennsylvania Basically, Neale is saying Electoral. That disrupts the Electoral College provides additional leverage to states that have a smaller.... Wegman: Its a great question, and state governments retained the to! Rural Americans and remain devoted to the electors help you with your studies it is beyond dispute that our to. Candidates focus on swing states needs more than other states in order to provide a method indirect! Use the Electoral College aims for presidents who represent the states in order to provide a method of the... Came the decision that the person elected would not gain too much power and independence may have been published...