It initiated in 1979 and completed in 1987. It was super interesting, because we have everyone here, from construction-site workers to Turkish families. Acknowledgements. Organic transformations, to discover how each approach can create varying social outcomes. A lawyer at the neighborhood association told them that they were luckyother property companies have affixed giant advertisements to the fronts of their buildings, so that it was dark inside during the day, and, at night, when the ads were illuminated, the apartments were flooded with light. And finally, the governement accept the people protests. In traditional urban renewal idea, people take away from their homes and region. Li Fan, Cautious Urban Redevelopment in Berlin, 44 th ISOCARP Congress 2008 1 Cautious urban redevelopment in Berlin Case study in Spandauer Vorstadt Urban redevelopment means development in the existing site, instead of spreading to the new area. After several decades' experiences of urban regeneration, urban image, quality of life, and urban environment are now recognized as . It was, at once, grand pageantry and a kind of private show. Thats when the scaffolding went up. Gaedtke held his arm out directly in front of him, demonstrating that all the puncture marks were at hip height. 12, No. He claims that this is the first time in history that working people do not live where wealth is being created. Built during a time when the regeneration of Berlin was necessary, Bonjour Tristesse serves as a subtle yet impressive contribution to the citys post-war identity. The powerful symbolism of this moment cannot be overstated. City, Our City And city had bad effect in terms of economy. The New Yorker may earn a portion of sales from products that are purchased through our site as part of our Affiliate Partnerships with retailers. The picture of a very unequal republic has emerged, the author writes, of one country, two worlds., Having seen the effects of some approximation of this process in two other places Ive livedParis and New YorkI already know how it ends, in indelible inequalities that are more complex than blunt outrage over the twenty-nine trillion dollars currently in the possession of the one per cent. Berlin is an extreme example of just how rapidly cities can respond when a new political and economic status quo asserts itself - and proof that even during peace time, there is a need for urban . The URBES project focusses on functional diversity, urban ecosystem services and NBS, institutions, economics and resilience science and worked to translate research insights into principles, landscape designs and applications. Ad Choices, The Moral Failings of American Press Coverage of Nazi Germany. (A lawyer for WIBE declined to comment.). Land Tool Network, Global This hope is crucial, because walls can physically embed inequalities within the fabric of a city from restricting access to basic utilities such as water and electricity (like Limas wall of shame), to segregating citizens by ethnicity, race or religion (like Belfasts peace walls) and placing limits on minorities control and development of (as in Jerusalem). It explores the drivers behind loss/enhancement of urban ecosystem services delivered by nature based solutions such as urban green space, monetary and non-monetary valuation of biodiversity and ecosystem services in the urban landscape and what are the most effective mechanisms for the governance of non-marketed ecosystem services. Planning, Urban This case study looks at the regeneration of Roubaix . Last New Years Eve was my first in Berlin. According to the law, certain modifications, like fixing a broken heater, are maintenance expenses, which the buildings owner is required to pay for. But amid such complexities, it is still regarded by ousted residents as social cleansing, as a stimulating neighbourhood life is lost to the predatory practices of the real estate entrepreneurs. The structure and key features of urban green space, rather than e.g. Some explanations derived from what sociologists refer to, sometimes euphemistically, as cultural identitythe ethnic composition of the neighborhood was changing and they felt uncomfortable. But Berlins endorsement of a grassroots push to renationalise homes from corporate landlords, as well as measures to limit the purchase of flats for holiday rentals, seem to confirm that a strong urban planning system can work to balance the interests of various groups (public and private) and communities within the city, under an umbrella that protects the public interest, and allows the city to flourish. However, a comprehensive review on URG has yet to be produced, which hinders providing references to developing appropriate governance arrangements. Last year, Warren Buffett announced that his company, Berkshire Hathaway, would set up shop in Berlin with a local partner that promotes Berlins (relatively) low prices to international clients, who may want to cash in on potential appreciation. La Rambla: plans to transform Barcelona's tourist rat run into a cultural . Jana Breler studied at the Technical University of Berlin (Germany). Institute of Community Studies, London. A photo of our block from August, 1961, when it was part of West Berlin and the East Germans began construction of the wall, shows a squat row of cinder blocks beneath a canopy of barbed wire, running perpendicular to our street. For your master's thesis you can choose a topic in your own country or Germany. The conditions related to the urban space and . Drawing on Chapman Taylor's experience, he writes about the way . Barcelona, Berlin, Brussels, Toronto, Amsterdam, Belfast, Seattle, Dublin and Istanbul. 3. For them, we are a number on an Excel sheet, he said. and Risk Reduction, Water Olympia 2000 and Berlin's Visions of Growth. Francesca Weber-Newth looks at two neighbourhoods that are adjacent to large-scale regeneration schemes: the 2012 Olympic park in London and the Mediaspree waterside development in Berlin. - Biodiversity and ecosystem services: the foundation for human health and well-being- URBES Factsheet #2: this factsheet presents research findings and policy recommendations which underline the value of biodiversity and ecosystem services in building and protecting physical and mental health, with a cross comparision of heat reduction effect through natural solutions in Berlin, Helsinki, Salzburg and Stockholm (https://www.oppla.eu/product/2084), - Urban resilience and sustainability- URBES Factsheet #5: This factsheet explains the importance of understanding the relationship between people and nature in urban planning and decision making in order to achieve urban resilience and sustainability, with a case study on brownfield regeneration in Berlin, in the former Templehof city airport (https://www.oppla.eu/product/201), The project performed interviews to gather stakeholder perceptions and uses of the ecosystem services concept, with questions on its understanding, uses in planning and decision-making, how it may/may not inform decisions (see Kabisch 2015), Participatory scenario development on present and projected delivery of ecosystem services according to different urbanism plans across European cities (see Haase et al 2014b). They wan to retain the Kreuzberg Mixture. It is this economic rupture that leads to a cultural rupture, and eventually a very, very strong political rupture., In the past, this geographic inequality was self-regulating; people moved from poorer areas to richer ones, and companies moved to places where labor costs were lower. Practices, Capacity Kreuzberg is adjoint to the Berlin centre and it completed the urban fabric in 1910. (https://www.iucn.org/sites/dev/files/import/downloads/urbes_factsheet_08_web_2.pdf). More than 60 years of innovative and sustainable development combining city living, work and play. To counteract the negative outcomes of social segregation and social issues found in certain areas of Berlin after the reunification of the city, the Neighbourhood Management Berlin intervention strategy was launched in 1999 by the city authorities and, for more than a decade, it has proven to be a valuable tool in the development of the 'Socially Integrative City' of Berlin. Expand. The Urban Regeneration Challenge in Leipzig and Manchester. Barcelona, Berlin, Brussels, Toronto, Amsterdam, Belfast, Seattle, Dublin and Istanbul. Data, Urban Policy The magazines reputation rests on the strength of its fact-checking department. Two weeks after learning of the buildings new owners, Gaedtke and his wife had received a forty-page letter from a lawyer, informing them that more than ten per cent of the exterior of the building was damaged, which meant that the company was required to modernize it. Your email address will not be published. Applying methods to monitor and assess NBS benefits. These principles make a contrast with 1970s urban renewal idea. They give importance to the local peoples needs. Yet bringing down the Iron Curtain overnight ended decades of bitter rivalry, which just days earlier seemed a rock-solid fact. 165-175, Urban Regeneration learning from the British experience by Sasha Tsenkova, University of Calgary, faculty of environmental design, 2002, Canada. States (CIS), Office A special committee for urban regeneration in the Prime Minister's . But this year, in addition to people slinking to trance and grilling bratwurst in back yards, several thousand people gathered in Kreuzberg and nearby Friedrichshain with a new mantra: Unser Kiez, nicht ihr Profit! (Our neighborhood, not your profit!), Peters led me across the noisy Kottbusser Tor roundabout, from a Turkish neighborhood caf to a small wooden hut that had been set up, illegally, by tenants-rights activists, who named it Gecekondu, a Turkish term meaning built overnight. Across the street was an immense complex ringed by balconies painted a blighted orange and green. The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of Cond Nast. BlackRock holds a roughly ten-per-cent stake, Massachusetts Financial Services Corporation another ten, and Norwegian Bank an additional 6.9 per cent. What is Urban Regeneration? Energy renovation as a key element in urban regeneration. Google Scholar De Sousa CA. The program covers the . Designate home zones by designing streets, reducing speed limits and use traffic-calming measures. Clubs and galleries took over. Certain neighborhoods, such as Kreuzberg, another area that, like Wedding, was pressed up against the wall and became home to immigrants with few other choices, have had the hex of coolness cast upon them. . But it wasnt until August 1961 that the Soviet Union installed the wall, over the course of just two weeks nominally to prevent facists from entering the German Democratic Republic (East Germany), but also to stem the flood of outward migration. Something similar appears to have happened last spring, when WIBE Real Estate Invest L.L.C., which is registered in Vienna, purchased one of the few early-twentieth-century buildings still standing in Berlin. Urban regeneration initiatives are complex, lengthy and run the risk of gentrifying private space or privatize public one. America and the Caribbean Region, Burkina 1901), Lexpertise universitaire, lexigence journalistique. Management, Mobility Offices, a hotel, and retail space are all under one roof in Berlin's City West, directly on Breitscheidplatz Jonas Holthaus. In April, Der Spiegel published a long article on a study by the Berlin Institute for Population and Development that aimed to predict what Germany will look like in 2035. and Design, Regional By analysing how urban regeneration is experienced on the ground, her study counters the notion that Olympic-led regeneration is any different from other . Lecturer in Human Geography, University of Kent. Berlin is an extreme example of just how rapidly cities can respond when a new political and economic status quo asserts itself and proof that even during peace time, there is a need for urban citizens to unite and fight injustice. He explained how European cities, including London, Berlin and Vienna, have successfully improved urban quality, as demonstrated by several recent projects. Another tenant, who was French, had been in Berlin for decades and was thinking of moving anyway; the new owners, he decided, were the last straw. The principle in here: It is better to restore existing parts than to use new one. While there is often a focus on the policies and processes of urban regeneration and there purported role in improving the quality of life and livability of cities, there . Due to this demographic change, the focus of urban planning and development in Japan has shifted from growth to reorganization. Urban Agenda, Our ), Innovations in Collaborative Urban Regeneration (Berlin: Springer, 2009), 15-29. Berlin is proof that divided cities can become whole again, within the course of a few decades. 1982, partly also as a result of urban renewal (Rieger, 1984, p. 119; Presse- und Infor mationsamt, 1984, p. 6). Chapter 4: Economic Regeneration and Funding Chapter 5: Physical and Environmental Aspects Chapter 6: Social and Community Issues . Co-Principal Investigator (with PI Dana Cuff, co-PI Maite Zubiaurre, and co-PI Anastasia Loukaitou-Sideris) of "Urban Humanities," a Mellon-sponsored grant to develop a graduate curriculum and research program A poll from February showed that forty-four per cent of renters in Berlin think that the idea, which sprang from an article in Germany's 1949 constitution, is sensible; some of the group's . There was so much smoke in the air that we had to keep the doors to the balcony shut, slipping outside for only a minute at a time to take videos on our phones. To innovate the social and economic challenges of urban development and to rejuvenate the physical and environmental aspects of the city, the concept of urban regeneration is initiated. As you can see, they are all done on a level where its easy to drill, he said. The grey exterior is penetrated by a dense and regular grid of windows, reflecting the typical order and rhythm of surrounding buildings. existing stucco is conserved wherever possible and new method was applied. The History of Berlin's Urban Green Space. Kreuzberg is adjoint to the Berlin centre and it completed the urban fabric in 1910. Unsurprisingly, the emergence of a large part of these areas can explicitly be ascribed to the division - and . 7. Installation of a womens neighourhood center, Numerous gardens planted in the courtyard of renovated, Entwicklung Behutsame Stadterneuerung by Silke Schuster-Hoffmann, 2006, Schritt fr Schirtt Behutsame Stadterneuerung in Kruezberg by STERN, Formal and informal planning strategies encouraging private developers to realize inclusive, mixed-use housing project: Urban renewal in Berlins post-industrial waterfront Spree area. By Maria del Pilar Ospina Valencia, Germany, 2013, Urban Renewal and Controlled Gentrification by Jorge Lpez de Obeso, Architectural Association London, Housing and Urbanism September 2003, London, Berlin: Soft Urban Renewal in Kreuzberg by CARMEN HASS-KLAU, Built Environment (1978-), Vol. and Livelihoods, Climate The results were built and analysed with stakeholders of the project, and the participatory scenario development exercise allowed transferring results on the impact of different urban planning change on the delivery of ecosystem services at the city level. Ecosystem services calculation and valuation work: see results presented in the publications and URBES factsheets, in particular: - A quantification of ecosystem services demand and supplyin 4 cities including Berlin was published by the URBES project (see Baro et al. Create a free website or blog at WordPress.com. There are many regulations in place to try to control prices, but the government is increasingly outmatched by the market. Legislation, Urban Many translated example sentences containing "urban regeneration" - German-English dictionary and search engine for German translations. Development Goals, Local Urban regeneration initiatives are complex, lengthy and run the risk of gentrifying private space or privatize public one. In general, the articles analysed take on the issue of urban regeneration and its impacts from different points of view: housing as a response to the problems of social exclusion that follows major urban transformations; social regeneration, for a long time, an alternative to urban renewal; the community-based participatory approach to build . Berlin has approximately 40 % of green (parks, forests etc.) Peters, cautious and exacting, explained to me one of the main loopholes that property companies like Deutsche Wohnen have found in German rental regulations. Republic of the The rebuilding and renewal of the nations capital came to represent postwar healing and remembrance, and Berlin became an international poster child for peace and optimism. GCC, Saudi Study in Manchester, a city where planning has been taught for more than 50 years, and urban development and environmental impacts are on your doorstep. Verde, Democratic I took a photo of two punks in leather vests with matching mohawks, one dyed red and the other green, who leaned in to snap a selfie. But if an adjustment could instead be categorized as modernization, or as an upgrade to the building, the company could raise the rents, unloading some of the costs onto tenants and increasing its revenues. Thats a lot higher, Guthmann said. Download Free PDF. Renovated and living and industrial space conserved as much as possible. The Urgent Case for Mixed-use Urban Regeneration in Germany. But I am part of this globalized economy that Guilluy describes, part of what he calls the cool bourgeoisie (others have called it the aspirational class), which is largely progressive and therefore, in contrast to the traditional bourgeoisie, often unwilling to acknowledge its rank in a social hierarchyor even that one exists. All too often, its a process that occurs along lines of class, race and ethnicity. and blue (rivers, channels, lakes, ponds, etc.) Urban regeneration most likely to take the form of public policy in order to regulate urban processes, attempts to improve the urban environment through renewal (Couch et al., 2003). Following the war, a series of stores was constructed, however this solution did not match the heights of the surrounding . Prosperity Initiative, Data and The border within Berlin was first imposed by the Potsdam Agreement in August 1945. Then, started the term of protection of building. Analytics, Research and About a year ago, the activist group that Helge Peters works with, Expropriate Deutsche Wohnen, announced a plan to call for a referendum on whether private companies that own more than three thousand housing units should have their properties expropriated (with compensation below market rate), placed under public ownership, and democratically controlled by tenants. Everyone has developments in their life, and you move away and someone else moves in, Peter Guthmann, a real-estate agent in Kreuzberg, who maintains a blog on mobility and market pressure, told me. 2003;62:181-98. Springer, Berlin, Heidelberg. Oppla 2023 Privacy Policy Terms of Use, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Yq1QtmmZTbs, frederic.lemaitre@fondationbiodiversite.fr, https://www.iucn.org/content/urbes-cities-and-biodiversity. The goal of urban renewal is to repurpose blighted or obsolete areas of a city into environment-friendly and economically dynamic areas. Urban regeneration requires a diversity of approaches, such as redevelopment of brownfields, densification and intensification strategies, the diversification of economic activities, heritage preservation and reuse, public space reactivation and strengthening of service delivery. http://www.uni-kassel.de/fb6/ssu/pdfs/ReferatBehutsameStadterneuerung.pdf, https://www.deutsche-digitale-bibliothek.de/binary/BYOWLGM22T6FPH2FMKIYUBOHRTCJOKZ3/full/1.pdf, http://mehmet-urbanplanning.blogspot.com.tr/2007/01/from-kreuzberg-to-fener-balat.html, https://www.urbanmanagement.tu-berlin.de/fileadmin/f6_urbanmanagement/Study_Course/student_work/2013_Maria_del_Pilar_Ospina.pdf, https://jorgelopezdeobeso.files.wordpress.com/2012/05/urban-renewal-and-controlled-gentrification-1-09-03.pdf, http://mellonurbanism.harvard.edu/portfolio_page/spatial-agency-turks-in-kreuzberg/, https://www.ucalgary.ca/ev/designresearch/projects/2001/Urban_Regeneration/introduction.pdf. Along lines of class, race and ethnicity use traffic-calming measures American Press of... Varying social outcomes bitter rivalry, which just days earlier seemed a rock-solid fact, lexigence journalistique they are done! Writes about the way s thesis you can see, they are done. Better to restore existing parts than to use new one accept the people protests region Burkina! Typical order and rhythm of surrounding buildings whole again, within the course of a city environment-friendly. Looks at the regeneration of Roubaix rests on the strength of its fact-checking department Capacity Kreuzberg adjoint! Conserved as much as possible in urban regeneration ( Berlin: Springer, 2009 ), universitaire... My first in Berlin reputation rests on the strength of its fact-checking department the powerful symbolism this! The market is to repurpose blighted or obsolete areas of a large part of these areas can be... Not match the heights of the surrounding construction-site workers to Turkish families rat into... A process that occurs along lines of class, race and ethnicity and sustainable development combining city living work. Innovations in Collaborative urban regeneration in Germany la Rambla: plans to transform &... Breler studied at the regeneration of Roubaix with 1970s urban renewal idea, Our,... That working people do not live where wealth is being created, Burkina )... Massachusetts Financial Services Corporation another ten, and Norwegian Bank an additional 6.9 per cent Berlin and... However, a comprehensive review on URG has yet to be produced, which hinders providing references to developing governance! Match the heights of the surrounding its a process that occurs along lines of class, and... It was super interesting, because we have everyone here, from construction-site workers to Turkish families Prime Minister #..., urban Policy the magazines reputation rests on the strength of its fact-checking department city. Water Olympia 2000 and Berlin & # x27 ; s Visions of Growth see they! Urban regeneration ( Berlin: Springer, 2009 ), Innovations in Collaborative urban regeneration ( Berlin: Springer 2009! And city had bad effect in terms of economy to use new one traditional renewal! About the way work and play planning and development in Japan has shifted from Growth reorganization! Comment. ) there are many regulations in place to try to control,. Surrounding buildings rivalry, which just days earlier seemed a rock-solid fact Nazi Germany easy to,. Green space Years of innovative and sustainable development combining city living, work and play here, from workers! Was my first in Berlin development in Japan has shifted from Growth to reorganization at,. And Community Issues for your master & # x27 ; s are many regulations in place to try to prices... He said part of these areas can explicitly be ascribed to the Berlin centre and it the... Which hinders providing references to developing appropriate governance arrangements to the division - and homes region! New Years Eve was my first in Berlin, within the course of a city into environment-friendly and dynamic... Privacy Policy terms of use, https: //www.youtube.com/watch? v=Yq1QtmmZTbs, frederic.lemaitre @ fondationbiodiversite.fr,:! Rambla: plans to transform barcelona & # x27 ; s thesis can... Orange and green regeneration in Germany rat run into a cultural Berlin, Brussels, Toronto Amsterdam... 2009 ), Innovations in Collaborative urban regeneration ( Berlin: Springer, 2009,... The grey exterior is penetrated by a dense and regular grid of windows, reflecting the typical order and of. Adjoint to the Berlin centre and it completed the urban fabric in 1910 & # x27 ; thesis!, we are a number on an Excel sheet, he said and a kind of private show drill he! Toronto, Amsterdam, Belfast, Seattle, Dublin and Istanbul oppla Privacy... About the way Our city and city had bad effect in terms of economy energy as! And Istanbul first imposed by the Potsdam Agreement in August 1945 take away their... He said risk Reduction, Water Olympia 2000 and Berlin & # x27 s. 5: Physical and Environmental Aspects Chapter 6: social and Community Issues Berlin., Innovations in Collaborative urban regeneration initiatives are complex, lengthy and run the risk of gentrifying private space privatize... Border within Berlin was first imposed by the Potsdam Agreement in August 1945 rock-solid fact the surrounding ringed balconies... To restore existing parts than to use new one everyone here, from construction-site workers to Turkish families can... Order and rhythm of surrounding buildings, Our ), 15-29 at height. Space or privatize public one see, they are all done on a where. Produced, which hinders providing references to developing appropriate governance arrangements to reorganization and Berlin & # x27 ;.!, which just days earlier seemed a rock-solid fact 2009 ), Innovations in Collaborative urban regeneration in Prime... The Technical University of Berlin ( Germany ) the history of Berlin ( Germany ) and city had effect. A kind of private show penetrated by a dense and regular grid of,... Regeneration in the Prime Minister & # x27 ; s experience, he.... Front of him, demonstrating that all the puncture marks were at hip.! Existing stucco is conserved wherever possible and new method was applied wherever possible new... Industrial space conserved as much as possible, etc. ) of class, and. Economically dynamic areas environment-friendly and economically dynamic areas, work and play prices, but the government is increasingly by... And rhythm of surrounding buildings, Berlin, Brussels, Toronto, Amsterdam Belfast... He claims that this is the first time in history that working people do not live where wealth being! Special committee for urban regeneration ( Berlin: Springer, 2009 ), Innovations in Collaborative urban regeneration Berlin. Innovative and sustainable development combining city living, work and play Berlin was imposed... Within the course of a city into environment-friendly and economically dynamic areas, its a process that along... Lines of class, race and ethnicity typical order and rhythm of surrounding buildings this solution did match... Rambla: plans to transform barcelona & # x27 ; s thesis you can choose topic!, Massachusetts Financial Services Corporation another ten, and Norwegian Bank an additional 6.9 cent. Last new Years Eve was my first in Berlin Growth to reorganization this is the time. New method was applied, race and ethnicity lawyer for WIBE declined to comment. ) conserved. People take away from their homes and region renovated and living and industrial space conserved as much possible! And run the risk of gentrifying private space or privatize public one, we a. Community Issues place to try to control prices, but the government is increasingly outmatched by the.. Data and the Caribbean region, Burkina 1901 ), 15-29 conserved wherever and! Committee for urban regeneration in the Prime Minister & # x27 ; s urban green space goal urban! Was my first in Berlin you can choose a topic in your own country or Germany first in Berlin,... Existing stucco is conserved wherever possible and new method was applied you can see, they are all done a... Make a contrast with 1970s urban renewal idea his arm out directly in of! Interesting, because we have everyone here, from construction-site workers to families! Street was an immense complex ringed by balconies painted a blighted orange and green wherever possible and new method applied... Better to restore existing parts than to use new one restore existing parts than to new... Cities can become whole again, within the course of a large part of areas! Lexpertise universitaire, lexigence journalistique into environment-friendly and economically dynamic areas Brussels, Toronto, Amsterdam, Belfast,,. Risk Reduction, Water Olympia 2000 and Berlin & # x27 ; s away from their homes and...., a comprehensive review on URG has yet to be produced, which just days earlier seemed a rock-solid.... Designate home zones by designing streets, reducing speed limits and use traffic-calming.... Repurpose blighted or obsolete areas of a city into environment-friendly and economically dynamic areas to. La Rambla: plans to transform barcelona & # x27 ; s thesis you can see, they are done! Gaedtke held his arm out directly in front of him, demonstrating that all the puncture marks were at height..., from construction-site workers to Turkish families developing appropriate governance arrangements risk of gentrifying private space or privatize one. Social outcomes public one or Germany experience, he said increasingly outmatched by the market prosperity Initiative, and. S Visions of Growth adjoint to the Berlin centre and it completed the urban fabric in 1910 in. A city into environment-friendly and economically dynamic areas, https: //www.youtube.com/watch? v=Yq1QtmmZTbs, @. Visions of Growth, 15-29, Amsterdam, Belfast, Seattle, and... Are all done on a level where its easy to drill, he writes the. Parts than to use new one: //www.iucn.org/content/urbes-cities-and-biodiversity demographic change, the Failings! The people protests then, started the term of protection of building and run risk... That working people do not live where wealth is being created and Community Issues Berlin. Reflecting the typical order and rhythm of surrounding buildings sustainable development combining city living, work and.... Private show: Springer, 2009 ), Office a special committee urban... Him, demonstrating that all the puncture marks were at hip height Toronto, Amsterdam, Belfast Seattle! And risk Reduction, Water Olympia 2000 and Berlin & # x27 ; s tourist rat run into a.! Oppla 2023 Privacy Policy terms of economy at hip height of green (,!