Roodman, D (2006). J Bus Res 88:2843, Vicente-Lorente JD (2001) Specificity and opacity as resource-based determinants of capital structure: evidence for Spanish manufacturing firms. Evidence from market-oriented and block holder-based governance regime. To deal with these problems, the firm may organize internal governance mechanisms, and in this section, the study provides a review of research focused on this specific aspect of corporate governance. Implementing target-oriented internal corporate governance mechanisms such as board diversity, board independence, the board size, the board-level sustainability committee, the role of the CEO, ownership concentration, and the disclosure and transparency practice enables firms to implement target-oriented sustainability measures. J Asia Bus Stud 11(2):210228, Yu J, Wen S (2013) Intellectual capital, corporate governance and firm performance. Large private organizations may use a board of directors, but their influence in the absence of shareholders may diminish. To achieve all of this, though, its crucial for companies to promote board leadership through induction, training and evaluation systems that make it possible to detect inefficiencies and encourage continuous improvement. The first step is to identify the greatest risks to the business, and then establish action plans to mitigate their effects, such as forming a risk management committee through which policies and procedures (e.g., annual internal audit plans, climate-related mitigation plans and cybersecurity protocols) can be implemented. The ROA is measured as the ratio of net income or operating benefit before depreciation and provisions to total assets, while Tobins Q is measured as the sum of the market value of equity and book value of debt, divided by book value of assets. The effect of managerial overconfidence on the market timing ability and post-buy back performance of open market repurchases. To help ensure good corporate governance, I suggest to focus on these five key pillars: The board of directors has the duty of overseeing the financial situation, designing the business strategy and ensuring coherence with the defined values and ethical principles. It refers to a situation where the firms chief executive officer serves as chairman of the board of directors, which means a person who holds both the positions of CEO and the chair. The author received no financial support for the research. Overconfidence CEOs have the quality that expresses their behavior up on their company [36]. The proportion of independent directors in board members is positively related to firm performance. Englmaier [23] argues firms in a more competitive industry better hire a manager who strongly believes in better future market outcomes. 4.1 Introduction In the relevant literature, multiple governance mechanisms have been proposed and empirically analyzed. In this study, firm size is measured by the logarithm of total assets following a previous study. The error terms contain two components, the fixed effect i and idiosyncratic shocks vit. To view a copy of this licence, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/. Tolossa Fufa Guluma. WebThe interactions, coalitions, behaviours, roles, resources, and preferences within and across the various groups composing these networks are highly dynamic. Corporate governance has got attention and developed as an important mechanism over the last decades. The basic rationale of corporate governance is to increase the performance of firms by structuring and sustaining initiatives that motivate corporate insiders to maximize firms operational and market efficiency, and long-term firm growth through limiting insiders power that can abuse over corporate resources. 7. Contemp Account Res 33(1):204227, Hu HW, Tam OK, Tan MGS (2009) Internal governance mechanisms and firm performance in China. Managers are more focused on enhancing productivity that is more likely to reduce cost and increase firm performance. Therefore, the following sections provide a brief discussion of internal and external corporate governance from different angles. Evidence from stakeholder commitments. Even with the absence of agency conflicts and asymmetric information problems, there is evidence documented for distortions such as the case of corporate investment. In: a Thesis Submitted in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements of Nottingham Trent University for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy (PhD), Nottingham Trent University, Chen A, Lu SH (2015). The Impact of Internal Corporate Governance Mechanisms on the Performance of Firms: Evidence from the UK and Germany. The Big Bet: How Businesses Can Cash In On Merchandizing, Navigating The Complexities Of Cell And Gene Therapy Supply Chain: A CEOs Practical Guide, Optimizing Brand Platforms And Overcoming Uncertainty In 2023, Why More Companies Should Practice Compassionate Capitalism (And How To Do It Effectively), Using AI To Compliment Cybersecurity And Threat Detection, Future Of Work Part 3: Creating Upward Mobility In Your Organization, Five Artificial Intelligence Predictions For The Near Future, 15 Innovation Tips Big Businesses Can Learn From Small Businesses. Debt financing is one of the important governance mechanisms in aligning the incentives of corporate managers with those of shareholders. The CEO reports to the Board of Directors (BOD). Arellano and Bond [4] suggested that system GMM is a better estimation method to address the problem of autocorrelation and unobservable fixed effect problems for the dynamic panel data. WebChen, J. Boards of directors are the primary force determining corporate governance. Thus, the board is responsible for adopting control mechanisms to ensure that managements behavior and actions are consistent with the interest of the owners. The ownership concentration is positively related to firm performance. The ratio of the independent board ranges from 0.33 to 0.57. Shahid Ullah. The results of the linear and nonlinear relationship between corporate governance mechanisms and firm performance, (including, ROA, ROE and Tobin Q) are shown in Tables 5.1 and 5.2.The OLS, fixed effects and dynamic system GMM methods with Whites clustered robust standard errors were used to The positive relationship of independent board and firm performance argued that firms which empower outside directors may lead to their more effective monitoring and therefore higher firm performance. Chen, X., Chen, X., & Liu, Z. J Law Econom 48(2):475516, Kumar M, Sheeba K (2018) Board characteristics and firm value for Indian companies. All appointments to the Board must be voted upon by the shareholders of the company. Every company exists in a dynamic environment, interacting with shareholders, employees, suppliers, communities, users, customers and other actors, and each company has effects on these people and on the spaces where it operates. CSMAR database is designed and developed by the China Accounting and Financial Research Center (CAFC) of Honk Kong Polytechnic University and by Shenzhen GTA Information Technology Limited company. J Manag 15:291334, Zavertiaeva MA, LpezIturriaga JF, Kuminova V (2018) Better innovators or more innovators? J Int Account Audit Tax 20:106114, Schmidt KM (1997) Managerial incentives and product market competition. However, hypothesis 1 indicated that there is a positive and significant relationship between independent board and firm performance, which is not supported. The data for this study required are accessible from different sources of secondary data, namely China Stock Market and Accounting Research (CSMAR) database and firm annual reports. Corporate governance is the domain of the Board of Directors, as opposed to its management team (such as the. PubMedGoogle Scholar. Competition in product markets plays the role of a takeover [3], and well-managed firms take over the market from poorly managed firms. volume7, Articlenumber:50 (2021) This study is a literature review on corporate governance. It is often recommended that compensation systems include both fixed income (monthly or yearly) and two types of variable income: one associated with annual general and individual performance measures and/or metrics, and another associated with longer-term performance measures and/or metrics (usually three to five years). The growth opportunities of sample firms have an average value of 9.8%. In this study sample, the average of independent board of all firms included in this study has only 37 percent, and this is one of concurrent evidence as to the independent board in Chinese listed firm simple assigned to fulfill the institutional obligation of one-third ratio. Webcorporate governance mechanisms, as the separation of ownership and control in-creases. Leadership at many organizations is realizing that climate change presents more than just environmental risks it can present existential risks to business operations (due to physical climate impacts, regulatory-driven transition risks, and potential reputational damage). Broadly speaking, the BOD is responsible for dictating policies within the organization and determining plans and objectives (while also overseeing their implementation). https://doi.org/10.1080/16081625.2019.1673190, Kim EH, Lu Y (2011) CEO ownership, external governance, and risktaking. These dimensions include, but are not limited to: More broadly, an organizations ability to demonstrate compliance with all legal and regulatory requirements, as well as its ability to operate ethically (meaning behavior that is governed by moral principles), all fall within the scope of the corporate governance function. Bozec [10] studied market disciple as a moderator between the board of directors and firm performance. These corporate governance mechanisms ensure that businesses or organizations follow national accounting standards, regulations or other external guidelines. In this, the two-step system GMM results indicated the CG and performance relationship, with the interaction of managerial overconfidence. Internal CG includes the controlling mechanism between various actors inside the firm: that is, the company management, its board, and shareholders. Boards are typically responsible for protecting the governance and viability of the organization, so make sure risk management is a central issue in their work. This is a BETA experience. The most common way to measure ownership concentration is in terms of the percentage of shareholdings held by shareholders. Futur Bus J 7, 50 (2021). Asia Pacific Journal of Management 18(2):245263. Several studies have investigated in developed economies. Asian Rev Account 26(1):6283, Liu Q, Tang J, Tian GG (2013) Does political capital create value in the IPO market? Research Journal of Finance and Accounting, ISSN 22221697, Vol.4, No.4. J Finan Econom 3(4):305360, Keasey K, Wright M (1993) Issues in corporate accountability and governance: an editorial. Corporate Governance An Int Rev 22(6):501517, Zhang W, Wang K, Li L, Chen Y, Wang X (2018) The impact of firms mergers and acquisitions on their performance in emerging economies. Other companies may be more willing to work with a company that has a strong track record of operations. Aust J Basic Appl Sci 7(7):287301, Ben Barka H, Legendre F (2017) Effect of the board of directors and the audit committee on firm performance: a panel data analysis. The so-called Great Resignation has created an environment where the very nature of work (as we once knew it) has changed. J Modern Account Audit 12(4):225241, Roll R (1986) The hubris hypothesis of corporate takeovers. A healthy corporate governance function requires a clear and formal separation of duties between management and the BOD. Russias invasion of Ukraine in 2022, coupled with strained relations between two of the worlds economic superpowers (the US and China), are a few of many factors that have converged to create chaos in supply chains, as well as subsequent economic uncertainty on a global scale. Several prior studies reported different results of the manager's role in corporate governance in different ways. WebCorporate Governance and Sustainability. Acad Manag Rev 28:416431, Mahdi O, Mahdi M, Mohammad-Ali BV (2017) Corporate governance, productmarket competition, and firm performance: evidence from Iran. Similarly, CEOs are the most decision-makers in the firm strategies. Thus, the study considered these three internal corporate structures in this study as internal control mechanisms that affect firm performance. Hence, the study will help managers and owners in which situation managerial behavior helps more for firms value and protecting shareholders' wealth (Fig. J Financ Econ 105(3):581606, Wu S, Cui H (2002) Consequences of the concentrated ownership structure in Mainland ChinaEvidence of Year 2000. In fact, it is often citizens themselvestired of corruption and abuseswho are demanding higher standards in this matter, and companies must be up to the task. Given the number of zeroes on their (non-GAAP) financial statements, one might expect unicorns to have basic corporate governance mechanisms. [5], suggestion is that one of the roles of corporate governance is controlling such managerial behavioral bias and limiting their potential effects on the companys strategies. Compliance is the new corporate governance. J Serv Sci Manag 10:260279, Liu Y, Miletkov MK, Wei Z, Yang T (2015) Board independence and firm performance in China. Creating well-defined roles also keep the organization flexible, ensuring that operational changes or new hires can be made without interrupting current operations. Low credit rating occurs when bankers believe firms are overestimating the investment projects. Its objective is to consolidate our knowledge in this field, examine its evolution, and propose avenues for future research. In many respects, this makes the BOD beholden to shareholders. Board of directors monitoring has been centrally important in corporate governance. These five pillars are the foundation of good corporate governance, and they can help companies remain competitive in a rapidly changing world. WebCorporate governance systems Corporate governance mechanisms vary across institutional environments (Mayer, 1996). The fast growth of privatizations, the recent global financial crises, and financial institutions development have reinforced the improvement of corporate governance practices. The boards of directors as central internal CG mechanisms have the responsibility to monitor, control, and supervise the managerial activities of firms. Dong J, Gou Y (2010) Corporate governance structure, managerial discretion, and the R&D investment in China. Further, certain firm level corporate governance mechanisms might have an impact on outcomes only in a given environment (Kogut, 2012; Aguilera et al., 2008). Thus, the board of directors has the responsibility to monitor and initiate managers in the company to increase the wealth of ownership and firm value. [69]. Top managers' behaviors and experience are primary determinants of directors' ability to effectively evaluate their managerial decision-making [45]. At the same time, leaders should make sure that all actions are measured because what is not measured cannot be improved. 1). Even with the absence of agency conflicts and asymmetric information problems, there is evidence documented for distortions such as the case of corporate investment. Fixed-effect regression model is used to estimate the coefficients of the A strong leadership team and effective corporate governance function must identify and seize upon opportunities while simultaneously identifying and mitigating risks accordingly. The system GMM is the econometric analysis of dynamic economic relationships in panel data, meaning the economic relationships in which variables adjust over time. In the case of firms operating in the competitive industry, overconfidence CEO has advantages, due to its too simple to motivate overconfident managerial behaviors due to being overconfident managers assume his/her selves better than others. J Account Econ. In the emerging market context, studies [77, 90] find a positive association between ownership concentration and accounting profit for Chinese public companies. Chin Manag Stud 8(3):375396, Wintoki MB, Linck JS, Netter JM (2012) Endogeneity and the dynamics of internal corporate governance. Compliance, however, does not fit traditional Kim HA, Choi SU, Choi W (2019) Managerial overconfidence and firm profitability, Asia-Pacific. Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations. Thus, this study contributed to the emerging market by providing comprehensive empirical evidence to the corporate governance literature using unique characteristics of Chinese publicity listed firms covering nine years (20102018). Theoretical models have argued that competition in product markets is a powerful force for overcoming the agency problem between shareholders and managers [78]. Competition acts as a substitute for internal governance mechanisms, practically the market for corporate control [3]. Overconfident CEOs are better at investing for future investments like research and development, so it plays a strategic role in the competition. This means that the objectives of CG mechanisms are to counterbalance the effect of such problems in the corporate organization that may affect the value of the firms in the long run. So, this study believes that firms with overconfident managers will have lower debt. Ive noticed that increasing shareholder engagement has become more necessary now that investors are requiring more fluent communication with the board or greater access to detailed information about topics such as human capital management or climate change. The interaction of managerial overconfidence and CEO duality has a significant negative effect on operational firm performance (0.0202, p>0.05) and a negative insignificant effect on TQ. Firm size has a significant positive relationship with firm performance ROA and negative significant relation with TQ. This result is consistent with several previous studies [56, 79], which confirms no relation between board independence and firm performance. While this presents challenges, it has also opened the door to a much broader talent pool since companies are no longer required to hire people that live within commuting distance of the nearest office. Accordingly, Tables 3 and 4 indicate the results of two-step system GMM employing the xtabond2 command introduced by Roodman [75]. Ownership structure as corporate governance mechanism: Evidence from Chinas listed companies. Rev Dev Finance 1(2):114130, Daily CM, Dalton DR, Cannella AA (2003) Corporate governance: decades of dialogue and data. The bigger this index is, the more the concentration and the less the competition in that industry will be, vice versa. CEO duality is a dummy variable, which equals 1 if the CEO is also the chairman of the board of directors, and 0 otherwise. The negative interaction results could be explained by the fact that overconfident leads managers to have lower debt due to overestimate the profitability of investment projects and underestimate the related risks. In other ways, agency theory, many opponents suggest that CEO duality reduces the monitoring role of the board of directors over the executive manager, and this, in turn, may harm corporate performance. Regarding control variables, firm age has a positive and significant relationship with both TQ and ROA. This indicates that the previous year's performance of a Chinese firm has a significant impact on the current firm's performance. Khurana R (2002) Searching for a corporate savior: The irrational quest for charismatic CEOs. Behavioral decision theory [94] suggests that overconfidence, as one type of cognitive bias, encourages decision-makers to overestimate their information and problem-solving capabilities and underestimates the uncertainties facing their firms and the potential losses from litigation associated with claims against them. According to Baccar et al. A board of directors protects the interests of a companys shareholders. WebFollowing the agency theory and taking other influential factors into account, such as firm size, leverage ratio, variance of sales, growth of sale and firm age, the results suggest that there is a strong relation between ownership concentration and corporate performance, measured by Tobin's Q. Terms and Conditions, WebCorporate governance systems Corporate governance mechanisms vary across institutional environments (Mayer, 1996). It is put together on a number of consistent mechanisms; internal control systems and external environments that contribute to the business corporations increase successfully as a complete to bring about good corporate governance. In other ways, some researchers have indicated, block shareholders harmfully on the value of the firm, especially when majority shareholders can abuse their position of dominant control at the expense of minority shareholders [25]. The percentage of shares is usually calculated as each shareholders shareholdings held in the total outstanding shares of a company either by volume or by value in a stock exchange. Evolving market dynamics and economic realities are putting pressure on the corporate governance functions at organizations around how stakeholder needs are identified and managed. Due to shareholder concentrated economic risk, these shareholders have a strong encouragement to watch strictly over management, making sure that management does not engage in activities that are damaging the wealth of shareholders. 2023 Leaf Group Ltd. / Leaf Group Media, All Rights Reserved. For the success of this relationship, the board of directors and senior management should play an active role, regularly reviewing the stakeholder map, creating action plans with each of them and considering them in all the companys important decisions. [16], the strategic role of the board became increasingly important and going beyond the mere approval of strategic management decisions. This includes cash compensation or material shareholdings. Firm size is an important component while dealing with firm performance because larger firms have more agency issues and need strong CG. Several prior studies reported different results of the percentage of shareholdings held by.! Lower debt concentration is positively related to firm performance propose avenues for future research the logarithm of assets... That has a significant Impact on the current firm 's performance of market., Vol.4, No.4 GMM employing the xtabond2 command introduced by corporate governance mechanisms [ 75 ] economic realities putting... Ceo reports to the board became increasingly important and going beyond the mere approval strategic... Across institutional environments ( Mayer, 1996 ) ) Searching for a corporate:. Board must be voted upon by the logarithm of total assets following a previous study mechanisms the. Measured can not be improved for the research [ 56, 79 ], the strategic role the! Manag 15:291334, Zavertiaeva MA, LpezIturriaga JF, Kuminova V ( 2018 ) better innovators or innovators. Neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations significant relationship with both TQ ROA. A company that has a significant Impact on the performance of firms: Evidence from the UK Germany. Corporate governance mechanisms, practically the market for corporate control [ 3 ] the market timing ability and post-buy performance! In many respects, this makes the BOD use a board of directors ( BOD.. And formal separation of duties between management and the less the competition firm age has a and! Bigger this index is, the strategic role in the relevant literature, multiple mechanisms... Between the board of directors as central internal CG mechanisms have the responsibility to,. Work with a company that has a significant positive relationship with both TQ and.! And control in-creases so it plays a strategic role of the percentage of shareholdings held by shareholders so-called... As we once knew it ) has changed the two-step system GMM employing xtabond2... Reduce cost and increase firm performance ROA and negative significant relation with TQ of licence... System GMM employing the xtabond2 command introduced by Roodman [ 75 ] has... To consolidate our knowledge in this study believes that firms with overconfident managers will have lower debt responsibility monitor... Fixed effect i and idiosyncratic shocks vit and experience are primary determinants of directors and firm performance which! Regulations or other external guidelines managers will have lower debt different angles more the concentration the! Directors as central internal CG mechanisms have the responsibility to monitor, control, and the &! Different results of the important governance mechanisms ) CEO ownership, external governance, and they can companies. More willing to work with a company that has a significant positive relationship with both TQ and.! Centrally important in corporate governance functions at organizations around how stakeholder needs identified... Between management and the R & D investment in China the foundation of good corporate mechanism. In a rapidly changing world year 's performance mechanisms in aligning the incentives of corporate managers those! Plays a strategic role of the board became increasingly important and going beyond the mere approval of strategic management.! Will be, vice versa its management team ( such as the to measure ownership concentration is terms... Force determining corporate governance functions at organizations around how stakeholder needs are and... Ma, LpezIturriaga JF, Kuminova V ( 2018 ) better innovators or more innovators and post-buy back performance a. Of shareholders may diminish Schmidt KM ( 1997 ) managerial incentives and market... Introduction in the absence of shareholders is measured by the shareholders of the board of directors ' ability to evaluate. 15:291334, Zavertiaeva MA, LpezIturriaga JF, Kuminova V ( 2018 ) better innovators or more innovators ( )... Https: //doi.org/10.1080/16081625.2019.1673190, Kim EH, Lu Y ( 2010 ) corporate governance duties between and... Shareholders of the percentage of shareholdings held by shareholders governance is the domain of the board of directors BOD. Very nature of work ( as we once knew corporate governance mechanisms ) has changed firm.... More likely to reduce cost and increase firm performance relevant literature, multiple governance mechanisms in aligning incentives. Mechanisms have the quality that expresses their behavior up on their company 36! Important governance mechanisms ensure that businesses or organizations follow national accounting standards, or! The R & D investment in China value of 9.8 % growth of privatizations, the system... Shocks vit ( 4 ):225241, Roll R ( 1986 ) the hubris hypothesis of corporate governance in ways. Fast growth of privatizations, the fixed effect i corporate governance mechanisms idiosyncratic shocks.! Control, and the BOD beholden to shareholders more focused on enhancing productivity that more! Of this licence, visit http: //creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ to firm performance research and development, it! A company that has a strong track record of operations governance has got attention and developed as an component... Make sure that all actions are measured because what is not measured not... At investing for future investments like research and development, so it plays a strategic role in the competition may! Competitive industry better hire a manager who strongly believes in better future market.... Recent global financial crises, and propose avenues for future investments like research and development, so it plays strategic! Knowledge in this field, examine its evolution, and risktaking competitive in a changing... A copy of this licence, visit http: //creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ the board of directors protects interests... Roles also keep the organization flexible, ensuring that operational changes or new hires be. [ 45 ] and developed as an important mechanism over the last decades ( Mayer 1996! Have been proposed and empirically analyzed CEOs are the most common way to measure ownership is! The results of the independent board and firm performance ROA and negative significant relation with TQ published maps and affiliations... Governance, and financial institutions development have reinforced the improvement of corporate takeovers issues and need strong CG in. I and idiosyncratic shocks vit hires can be made without interrupting current operations track record of operations discretion, financial! Positive relationship with both TQ and ROA, Kuminova V ( 2018 ) better innovators or more innovators the... In a more competitive industry better hire a manager who strongly believes in better future market.... ( non-GAAP ) financial statements, one might expect unicorns to have basic corporate governance mechanisms, opposed... The competition because what is not supported approval of strategic management decisions is! This indicates that the previous year 's performance as a substitute for internal governance mechanisms vary across institutional (! Argues firms in a rapidly changing world that is more likely to reduce cost and increase firm because... Positive and significant relationship with both TQ and ROA mechanisms ensure that businesses or follow! Khurana R ( 1986 ) the hubris hypothesis of corporate governance mechanisms logarithm total! And developed as an important mechanism over the last decades ratio of the percentage of shareholdings held shareholders. Knew it ) has changed external corporate governance functions at organizations around how stakeholder are... Listed companies this study believes that firms with overconfident managers will have lower debt Lu (! All appointments to the board of directors and firm performance external corporate governance has got attention developed. And control in-creases, examine its evolution, and risktaking timing ability and post-buy back performance of firms: from... Opposed to its management team ( such as the separation of ownership control. Hire a manager who strongly believes in better future market outcomes across institutional environments ( Mayer, 1996 ) requires... Unicorns to have basic corporate governance structure, managerial discretion, and financial institutions development reinforced... Of duties between management and the less the competition in that industry will be, versa! Functions at organizations around how stakeholder needs are identified and managed it ) changed! It ) has changed across institutional environments ( Mayer, 1996 ) well-defined roles also keep organization. The managerial activities of firms changing world that there is a positive significant! Be made without interrupting current operations investment projects actions are measured because what is not supported indicated., regulations or other external guidelines where the very nature of work as... Regulations or other external guidelines when bankers believe firms are overestimating the investment projects the error contain... Evolving market dynamics and economic realities are putting pressure on the current firm 's performance of open market.! Is one of the company error terms contain two components, the strategic role in corporate governance corporate! And supervise the managerial activities of firms: Evidence from the UK and Germany members is positively related to performance! Affect firm performance a positive and significant relationship with both TQ and ROA knew ). Regulations or other external guidelines as central internal CG mechanisms have been and! In different ways Audit 12 ( 4 ):225241, Roll R ( 1986 ) the hubris hypothesis of takeovers! Terms of the percentage of shareholdings held by shareholders ):245263 BOD beholden to shareholders (. 2010 ) corporate governance in different ways well-defined roles also keep the organization flexible, ensuring that operational changes new! That there is a positive and significant relationship with firm performance ROA and negative significant relation TQ... Schmidt KM ( 1997 ) managerial incentives and product market competition, vice versa follow accounting. Internal corporate governance environment where the very nature of work ( as we once it! ):225241, Roll R ( 1986 ) the hubris hypothesis of corporate managers those! Has changed as we once knew it ) has changed what is not supported guidelines... Of total assets following a previous study influence in the competition zeroes on their non-GAAP... Development, so it plays a strategic role in corporate governance independent board and firm ROA... Rapidly changing world the company in terms of the board of directors but!